Health · Healthcare & Policy · 2 hrs ago
Surgeon calls for police probe after 19 avoidable deaths at Aberdeen hospital
Surgeon Mohammed Habib has called for a police investigation into deaths linked to liver and pancreas operations at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary in Scotland.
An external review commissioned by NHS Grampian found that 19 patients died from avoidable complications between 2015 and 2021.
The review examined 45 cases, and Habib said it judged 19 of those deaths avoidable.
The death rate was reported as far above the national average for this type of surgery, though the figures cover different periods and case details.
Habib says he raised concerns from 2021 and that officials did not act quickly enough; NHS Grampian says a thorough investigation has taken place and some work is ongoing.
Scotland's First Minister John Swinney called the disclosures gravely concerning but rejected calls for a criminal investigation, saying reforms at the health board should bring improvements.
The liver and pancreas surgery unit has since been shut, and NHS Grampian says it will consider any new evidence and contact further affected people if needed.
A senior surgeon has called for a criminal investigation into NHS Grampian after an expert review found 19 patients died from avoidable surgery-related complications.
Dr Mohammed Habib says he repeatedly raised concerns about liver and pancreatic surgery at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary and that officials failed to act quickly enough.
The review examined cases from 2015 to 2021, and external experts reported that the death rate in the specialty reached 18% between 2017 and 2020.
Scotland’s first minister called the disclosures a matter of grave concern but rejected calls for a criminal investigation.
NHS Grampian says a thorough investigation has taken place and that it will consider any new evidence through appropriate processes.
- Who
- Dr Mohammed Habib, a consultant surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, is calling for an investigation. NHS Grampian and Scotland’s first minister are also involved.
- What
- Habib is seeking a police investigation into alleged corporate homicide after a review found 19 avoidable deaths linked to surgery.
- When
- The deaths covered by the review occurred between 2015 and 2021. Habib called for an investigation in November 2026.
- Where
- Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, run by NHS Grampian, in Scotland.
- Why
- Habib alleges that hospital and health board officials failed to act promptly on concerns about patient safety and surgery-related deaths.
Dr Mohammed Habib and Michael Marra
John Swinney and NHS Grampian
Criminal investigation
Dr Mohammed Habib and Michael Marra
Habib and Marra call for a police investigation into alleged systemic failures and corporate homicide.
John Swinney and NHS Grampian
Swinney rejected calls for a criminal investigation, saying leadership changes and urgent reforms should bring improvements.
Response to concerns
Dr Mohammed Habib and Michael Marra
Habib says institutions failed to act robustly on his reports and that accountability is being avoided.
John Swinney and NHS Grampian
NHS Grampian says a thorough investigation has taken place, some work is ongoing, and new evidence will be considered through appropriate processes.
The expert review covered surgery-related deaths during this period.
Habib formally raised serious concerns about what he believed were dozens of avoidable deaths.
External experts reviewed cases and concluded that 19 deaths were avoidable, according to Habib.
Habib spoke to Police Scotland.
An external expert said surgery should end at the unit, and the liver and pancreatic surgery department was later shut down.
Habib called for a criminal investigation, and the findings and allegations were discussed at Holyrood.
- Avoidable deaths
- 19 patients
- Review period
- 2015–2021
- Case study
- 19 avoidable deaths out of 45 cases, according to Habib
- Reported death rate
- Up to 18% in liver and pancreatic surgery between 2017 and 2020
- National fatality average
- 2–3% for the specialty, depending on the patient’s condition
- Hospital
- Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, Scotland
2 sources
What people are saying
They are avoiding accountability by not being transparent about what damage has been done, while promising heaven and earth going forward.
of the gravest concern
deserve answers and deserve justice.
Patient safety remains our highest priority.