Science & Tech · Science & Environment · 3 hrs ago
Underwater Data Centers Promise Lower Resource Use but Raise Environmental Concerns
Companies are testing underwater data centers as demand for computing grows and communities object to the land, water and energy used by facilities onshore.
Placing servers under the sea could use seawater for cooling and draw electricity from offshore wind or tidal power.
Microsoft tested the idea off Scotland’s Orkney Islands with Project Natick, but later discontinued the project without giving a concrete reason.
China launched an offshore wind-powered underwater data center this summer, while companies have proposed projects off Alaska and Maine.
The projects could affect marine life and habitats, with concerns including noise, warmer water and pollution.
Local opposition is already slowing one Maine proposal: Eastport suspended all data center development for six months while it considers a permanent ban, and the Passamaquoddy people oppose the project.
Commercial-scale underwater data centers are still years away, and proposals will need to contend with environmental and operational challenges, including repairs at remote sites.
Companies are proposing underwater and floating data centers to reduce the land, freshwater and electricity used by conventional facilities.
Seawater cooling and power from offshore wind or tidal energy could reduce some resource demands.
The technology also raises concerns about marine habitats, noise, electromagnetic exposure, warmer water and copper pollution.
Microsoft discontinued its underwater data center project after testing it near Scotland’s Orkney Islands.
Projects proposed in Alaska and Maine have drawn opposition from environmentalists and local communities.
- Who
- Data center developers and start-ups are proposing underwater projects; environmentalists and some local communities oppose them.
- What
- Companies are testing or proposing data centers under the sea or on ships, citing potential resource savings and raising environmental concerns.
- When
- Proposals have been made this year, and China launched an offshore wind-powered underwater data center this summer.
- Where
- Proposed sites include Alaska and the Bay of Fundy near Eastport, Maine; Microsoft tested a facility near Scotland’s Orkney Islands.
- Why
- Developers say underwater facilities could reduce land, freshwater and electricity use, including through seawater cooling and renewable power. Critics are concerned about effects on marine life and habitats.
Data center developers
Environmentalists and local opponents
Resource use
Data center developers
Underwater facilities could reduce freshwater, land and electricity use for cooling.
Environmentalists and local opponents
These potential savings do not resolve concerns about environmental effects on marine life and habitats.
Marine impacts
Data center developers
Developers have proposed subsea facilities, but the article does not state their responses to specific environmental objections.
Environmentalists and local opponents
Concerns include noise, electromagnetic exposure, warming water and copper pollution.
Maine proposal
Data center developers
DeepGreen Western Passage SPV LLC has applied to study the feasibility of a subsea hub near Eastport.
Environmentalists and local opponents
Eastport’s City Council suspended data center development for six months while reviewing a proposed permanent ban; the Passamaquoddy people also oppose the project.
Microsoft tested a data center submerged on the seafloor off Scotland’s Orkney Islands.
Microsoft said the Project Natick structure showed underwater data centers were feasible and practical.
Microsoft executive Noelle Walsh confirmed that the underwater project had been discontinued.
China launched an offshore wind-powered underwater data center.
Eastport’s City Council enacted a six-month suspension of data center development while reviewing a proposed permanent ban.
- Microsoft pilot
- Project Natick, off Scotland’s Orkney Islands
- Alaska proposal
- 1,650-acre underwater hyperscale data center
- Maine proposal
- Western Passage of the Bay of Fundy, near Eastport
- China patents
- 80% of the world’s underwater data center patents
- Eastport measure
- Six-month suspension of data center development
What people are saying
I'm not building subsea data centers anywhere in the world.