Politics · Other · 16 hrs ago
Moraes votes to keep restrictions on sale of Paraná state technology company
Justice Alexandre de Moraes voted to keep restrictions on selling Celepar, Paraná state's technology company.
Celepar holds residents' sensitive information, including health, biometric and public security data.
The state government says private control would not put the information at risk because public authorities would continue to hold it and could veto company decisions.
Moraes said the safeguards taken so far are not enough to protect residents' personal data, and cited uncertainty about separating sensitive databases.
Earlier, Justice Flávio Dino said a sale could proceed only if Paraná kept control of sensitive public security data, maintained direct oversight and submitted an impact report to the national data protection agency.
Justice Cristiano Zanin disagreed, saying the Supreme Court should not hear the case because it challenges steps in the sale process, not the state law allowing the sale.
The court's final decision is expected by November 30; if Zanin's view prevails, the sale could move forward.
Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes voted to keep restrictions on the planned sale of Paraná state technology company Celepar.
Moraes said measures taken by the state government so far do not adequately protect residents’ personal data.
He agreed with the conditions set by Justice Flávio Dino, including keeping control of sensitive public security databases and submitting an impact report to Brazil’s data protection agency.
Justice Cristiano Zanin disagreed, saying the Supreme Court should not hear the case because it challenges privatization actions rather than the state law authorizing the sale.
The court’s virtual plenary vote is scheduled to end on November 30.
- Who
- Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes voted to maintain restrictions on the sale of Celepar.
- What
- He voted to keep conditions on the privatization process, citing concerns about personal data protection.
- When
- The vote was reported on November 20, 2026. The court’s virtual plenary vote is scheduled to end on November 30.
- Where
- Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court; Celepar is a Paraná state company.
- Why
- Moraes said the state’s measures so far do not adequately protect residents’ personal data.
Paraná state government
PT and PSOL
Data protection
Paraná state government
The government argues that private control would not endanger information security because public authorities would continue to guard the data and retain veto power over company decisions.
PT and PSOL
The parties argue that the plan risks private exploitation of public databases and encroaches on the federal government’s authority to legislate on data protection.
Flávio Dino partially granted interim relief, allowing the sale to proceed only under specified data-protection conditions.
Alexandre de Moraes voted to maintain restrictions on the sale.
The Supreme Court’s virtual plenary vote is scheduled to end.
- Company
- Celepar, Paraná state technology company
- Contract
- Paraná hired B3 for R$1.4 million to structure the auction
- State law
- A law authorizing the sale was enacted in November 2024
- Interim conditions
- Preserve state control over sensitive public security databases, maintain direct oversight, and submit an impact report to ANPD
1 source
What people are saying
mere patrimonial assets alienable