World · Middle East · 9 hrs ago
Experts question Iran's claims of mine attacks in Strait of Hormuz
Iran's Revolutionary Guard claims more than 30 ships hit sea mines in the Strait of Hormuz since the start of November.
Experts say the alleged explosions have not been independently verified, and the damage shown in videos does not appear to match what mines would cause.
Iran says ships must seek its permission and use a northern route through the strait.
The claims may scare shipowners even without evidence, because the threat of an underwater attack can make crews and companies avoid an area.
Ship crossings are down 80 per cent from prewar levels, according to Lloyd's List Intelligence.
A tanker trade group says it cannot identify mines posing a risk to ships in the Gulf or the strait, though one ship was damaged after hitting a floating object.
Many shipowners are still avoiding the route while the conflict remains volatile.
Experts say Iran’s claims that ships have hit sea mines in the Strait of Hormuz lack independent verification.
The Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps says more than 30 ships have struck mines since the start of November.
Iranian announcements have often included low-resolution videos of smoke, but experts say the reported incidents do not fit the evidence.
Iran’s claims may still deter sailors and raise shipping costs, even if no mines are present.
Ship crossings are down 80 per cent from prewar levels, according to Lloyd’s List Intelligence.
- Who
- Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps has claimed mine attacks; naval and shipping experts have questioned those claims.
- What
- Iran says ships have struck sea mines in the Strait of Hormuz, but experts say the incidents have not been independently verified.
- When
- The IRGC has made such announcements almost daily since mid-October, and says more than 30 ships have hit mines since the start of November.
- Where
- The Strait of Hormuz.
- Why
- Experts say the claims may scare sailors, deter ships from crossing and raise costs.
Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps
Naval and shipping experts
Reported incidents
Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps
The IRGC says more than 30 ships have hit sea mines since the start of November.
Naval and shipping experts
Experts say the reported incidents lack independent verification and the observed damage does not fit what mines would cause.
Threat to shipping
Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps
Iran says ships must seek its permission and take a northern route through the strait.
Naval and shipping experts
Intertanko says it does not believe mines currently pose a risk to shipping in the Gulf or Strait of Hormuz.
The IRGC has made announcements about purported mine incidents almost daily.
The IRGC says more than 30 ships have hit sea mines.
The IRGC navy said two tankers carrying more than four million barrels of oil had hit a mine and exploded.
- Claimed ships hit by mines
- More than 30 since the start of November
- Ship crossings
- 80 per cent below prewar levels
- Tankers in Thursday claim
- Two, carrying more than four million barrels of oil
- Reported mine-risk incidents identified by Intertanko
- One instance of a ship hitting a floating object that caused waterline damage
What people are saying
From what I have seen so far, there has been almost zero evidence of any damage caused by sea mines
It’s possible to make an effective minefield with zero mines, if someone can make a credible claim that they have mined specific waters
If those reports were true, we would have independent verification quite quickly
Mines tend not to cause fires
Posts on X
🚫 CLAIM: Over recent days and weeks, Iranian-controlled media have reported Iranian claims that commercial vessels are hitting sea mines while transiting the Strait of Hormuz. These claims are FALSE. ✅ FACT: All internationally recognized primary transit routes through the
IRGC Navy: Two supertankers found in violation struck a naval mine and exploded while traversing an unauthorized route through the Strait of Hormuz.