Politics · Germany · 1 hr ago
Kretschmann defends military service as young people protest
Former Baden-Württemberg premier Winfried Kretschmann defended military service during a TV discussion about protests by young people in Germany.
An 18-year-old student named Elias said he did not want to fight or die in a war, but Kretschmann argued that defending the country would protect young people too.
Germany has not introduced compulsory military service, and Juso leader Philipp Türmer said the defence minister had indicated volunteers were currently enough.
Türmer said mixed messages about possible automatic rules, a parliamentary decision and a lottery had made the government’s position hard to understand.
Young people are divided on military service: a researcher said more than 30% in her data were firmly against it, while a larger share were more in favour.
A youth strike is planned for November 20, after protests that drew up to 120,000 people two weeks earlier.
Winfried Kretschmann defended discussing military service with young people during a television debate about youth protests against conscription.
He said people should consider whether they would risk their lives to defend their country and Europe.
Kretschmann proposed a general civic year in which people could choose how to serve the community.
A student identified as Elias said he did not want to fight or die, while Kretschmann said that view involved a serious mistake.
Juso leader Philipp Türmer said the government had explained its military-service policy poorly and that he now viewed defending democracy differently.
- Who
- Winfried Kretschmann, former Baden-Württemberg premier, and young people protesting military service. Juso leader Philipp Türmer and education researcher Nina Kolleck also took part in the debate.
- What
- Kretschmann defended discussing military service as an existential question and proposed a general civic year with a choice of service.
- When
- The television debate was reported on November 16, 2026. A further youth strike was called for November 20.
- Where
- On the German television programme Caren Miosga. The reports also mention protests in Berlin and Frankfurt am Main.
- Why
- The debate concerned young people’s opposition to military service and how they might defend their country and democracy.
Winfried Kretschmann
Young people protesting military service
Meaning of defence
Winfried Kretschmann
Defence is ultimately for the young and for the country, Kretschmann argued.
Young people protesting military service
Protesters object to being expected to fight and die; Elias said he did not want to do so.
Kretschmann completed military service, according to Bild.
Up to 120,000 young people took to the streets to protest government policy, t-online reported.
Reports covered Kretschmann’s debate with Türmer and Kolleck on Caren Miosga.
The movement Gen Z regelt called for another youth strike.
- Military service
- Kretschmann served 18 months of compulsory military service, according to Bild.
- Protest turnout
- Up to 120,000 young people, according to t-online.
- Next youth strike
- November 20, 2026.
- Proposed alternative
- A general civic year in which each person could choose how to serve the community.
2 sources
What people are saying
Whether I sacrifice my life for my country in an emergency is an existential question!
The Russians are massacring the old and abducting the children.
They explained it all miserably.
I do not want to fight in a war. I do not want to die.