Politics · France · 15 hrs ago
Debate over civil servants’ duty to obey returns in France
The group Nos services publics launched training on public servants’ rights and duties on Thursday, November 19.
In France, obeying the chain of command is the rule, while refusing an order is rare.
The debate has returned amid the possibility of the far right coming to power and civil servants facing political decisions they consider against republican values.
Similar concerns arose in 2024, before snap parliamentary elections, when some officials said they might disobey if the far right took power.
The National Rally warned it could sanction officials who refused its decisions, saying such refusals would challenge the legitimacy of an elected government.
The party did not win those elections, and the questions remained unresolved; no next step is specified.
The debate over whether French civil servants should disobey political orders has returned to public discussion.
The collective Nos services publics launched training on public employees’ rights and responsibilities on November 19.
Hierarchical obedience remains the rule in France’s public service, while disobedience is a rare exception.
The debate has revived amid the possibility of the far right coming to power.
In 2024, some civil servants said they would disobey if the far right took office, prompting the National Rally to warn of sanctions.
- Who
- French civil servants and the collective Nos services publics. The National Rally has also taken a position.
- What
- Debate has returned over whether civil servants should disobey political orders they consider contrary to republican values.
- When
- The collective launched training on November 19. The issue also arose in 2024.
- Where
- France.
- Why
- The discussion is set against the possibility of the far right coming to power and questions about how civil servants would respond to its orders.
Civil servants considering disobedience
National Rally
Response to political orders
Civil servants considering disobedience
Some civil servants said in 2024 that they would disobey if the far right took power.
National Rally
The National Rally said refusal to apply its decisions would challenge the legitimacy of a government elected at the ballot box.
Possible consequences
Civil servants considering disobedience
The source reports that some civil servants expressed willingness to disobey.
National Rally
The party threatened sanctions against those who refused to apply its decisions if it came to power.
After the dissolution of the National Assembly and before the snap legislative elections, some civil servants said they would disobey if the far right took power.
Nos services publics launched training on public employees’ rights and responsibilities.
Le Monde published an article on the renewed debate.
- Collective
- Nos services publics
- Training topic
- Public employees’ rights and responsibilities
- Training date
- November 19
- General rule
- Hierarchical obedience
- Exception
- Disobedience is rare
- Earlier debate
- 2024