Entertainment · Music · 2 hrs ago
Producer Sues Travis Scott and Don Toliver Over ‘What to Do?’ Sample
Israeli producer Niv Kalisky is suing Travis Scott, Don Toliver and others over the 2019 song “What to Do?”
from the JACKBOYS album.
Kalisky, who works as Early Yellow, says he shared a beat with producers who later used it in the track.
He says no deal was reached for royalties from the sound recording, although he is credited as a songwriter and additional producer and has received publishing income.
The lawsuit also accuses Sony of using counter-notices to keep the song on streaming services after Kalisky sought takedowns.
“What to Do?”
has drawn hundreds of millions of plays across streaming platforms, according to the lawsuit, making the dispute about a substantial source of recording revenue.
Kalisky wants a share of the earnings and at least $1 million in damages; the defendants had not immediately commented, and the case will proceed in federal court in New York.
Israeli music producer Niv Kalisky is suing Travis Scott, Don Toliver, Sony Music and other collaborators over a sample in the 2019 song “What To Do?”
Kalisky, who performs as Early Yellow, alleges his beat was used without a licensing deal and that he was not paid master royalties.
The lawsuit says the song generated substantial streaming revenue and alleges defendants kept it available after copyright takedown requests.
Kalisky is seeking a share of recording revenue, an accounting of earnings and at least $1 million in damages.
Billboard reports Kalisky received publishing income as a songwriter, while the lawsuit concerns royalties for the sound recording.
- Who
- Niv Kalisky, an Israeli music producer who performs as Early Yellow, is suing Travis Scott, Don Toliver, Sony Music and other collaborators.
- What
- He alleges his beat was sampled in “What To Do?” without proper licensing or master royalties.
- When
- The lawsuit was filed on Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026.
- Where
- Federal court in New York.
- Why
- Kalisky says he was not paid for use of his recording and seeks royalties and damages.
This story does not have two clearly opposing sides.
What To Do?” was released on the JACKBOYS album.
Kalisky’s lawyers sent royalty requests, and his team submitted takedown requests to streaming services, according to the lawsuit.
Kalisky filed the copyright lawsuit in federal court in New York.
- Plaintiff
- Niv Kalisky, known as Early Yellow
- Song
- What To Do?
- Album
- JACKBOYS, released in 2019
- Streaming figures
- More than 270 million Spotify streams and more than 60 million YouTube plays, according to the lawsuit
- Damages sought
- At least $1 million
- Claimed ownership
- 50 percent of all rights in the sound recording, as requested in the lawsuit
2 sources
What people are saying
The business model of utilizing the valuable intellectual property owned by the plaintiff without paying or negotiating proper licensing has been an extremely lucrative practice for the defendants who continue with [the] willful unauthorized usage and monetization of the plaintiff’s protected work despite receiving several notices of breaches and even after valid ‘takedown’ notices were filed by the plaintiff
Producers are becoming more aware of their rights, and today our client chose to stand up for what he deserves.