Politics · India · 13 hrs ago
Supreme Court orders inquiry into three-year delay in ED bail appeal
The Enforcement Directorate’s appeal over Raman Singhal’s bail went unlisted at India’s Supreme Court for three years.
The court had issued notice in September 2023, but the case was not listed again before the court acted on November 4.
A bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant questioned how the case had remained out of the schedule and ordered an inquiry into the registry’s handling.
The inquiry is to be carried out by Supreme Court Secretary General Ajit Atri, who must file a report explaining the delay.
The court also dismissed the appeal, saying it would not consider a challenge to bail after more than three years.
The trial had already begun, with eight witnesses examined, and the court has directed the inquiry to establish why the appeal was not listed.
The Supreme Court ordered an inquiry into why the Enforcement Directorate’s appeal against bail for Raman Singhal was not listed for three years.
The appeal was last listed in September 2023, when the court issued notice to Singhal.
A bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant directed Secretary General Ajit Atri to investigate and report on the delay.
The court disposed of the appeal, saying it would not entertain a challenge to bail granted more than three years earlier.
The court was told that the trial had begun and eight witnesses had been examined.
- Who
- The Supreme Court ordered the inquiry. The appeal was filed by the Enforcement Directorate against bail granted to Raman Singhal.
- What
- The court ordered an inquiry into why the appeal was not listed for three years, and disposed of the appeal.
- When
- The order was reported on November 20, 2026. The appeal was last listed in September 2023.
- Where
- The Supreme Court in New Delhi.
- Why
- The appeal had not been listed for three years, and the bench sought an explanation for the lapse.
Supreme Court bench
Sidharth Dave
Reason for non-listing
Supreme Court bench
The bench questioned how the appeal could have gone unlisted for three years and ordered an inquiry.
Sidharth Dave
Dave said no one could manage listing in the Supreme Court because it was computer-based.
The appeal was last listed, and the court issued notice to Raman Singhal.
The bench issued an order after which it said the appeal would have been listed.
The Supreme Court ordered an inquiry into the delay and disposed of the appeal.
- Appeal
- Enforcement Directorate’s challenge to bail granted to Raman Singhal
- Last listing
- September 2023
- Inquiry lead
- Secretary General Ajit Atri
- Trial status
- Trial had commenced; eight witnesses had been examined
- Bench
- Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana
What people are saying
What is that great magic wand that was used by someone by which the case was not listed for hearing for three years?
The registry must explain this lapse.
What other inference can we draw from the non-listing?
no one could manage listing in SC as it was computer-based