World · Africa · 3 hrs ago
Buta family challenges order to exhume his remains
Simon Buta’s children are challenging an exhumation order in South Africa’s Constitutional Court.
Buta died in March 2024, and his family buried him at their homestead on a farm in Mpumalanga after the farm owner blocked a burial at an existing graveyard.
The Land Court ordered the family to remove his remains in July 2024, saying there was no established practice of burials at the homestead and Mafube Coal Mining had not consented.
The children argue that the law allows an occupier to bury a family member on the land when an established burial practice exists there.
They say the law applies to the farm as a whole, pointing to existing graves and past burials.
Mafube disputes that the graves establish a right to open a new grave at the homestead and says its mining project requires resettlement and grave relocation.
The Constitutional Court appeal raises questions about burial rights on land owned by others; no outcome is stated.
Simon Buta’s children are challenging a Land Court order requiring them to exhume his remains from their homestead on a farm in Mpumalanga.
The dispute has reached the Constitutional Court and concerns burial rights on land owned by others.
The family says Buta was entitled to be buried on the farm under the Extension of Security of Tenure Act.
Mafube Coal Mining argues that any established burial practice was limited to Graveyard 1, not the family homestead.
The Land Court granted the exhumation order on 18 July 2024.
- Who
- Simon Buta’s children are challenging the order; Mafube Coal Mining opposed the burial.
- What
- The children are appealing an order requiring them to exhume Buta’s remains from their homestead.
- When
- The Land Court issued the order on 18 July 2024; the appeal is before the Constitutional Court.
- Where
- On a farm in Mpumalanga owned by Mafube Coal Mining.
- Why
- The family says the law entitled Buta to be buried on the farm under an established burial practice. Mafube says that practice did not permit a new grave at the homestead.
Simon Buta’s children
Mafube Coal Mining
Established burial practice
Simon Buta’s children
Graves on the farm and previous owners’ permission show an established practice in respect of the land, the children argue.
Mafube Coal Mining
Graves do not establish a practice across the farm; any practice was confined to Graveyard 1, Mafube argues.
Right to bury at homestead
Simon Buta’s children
The law concerns burial practice in respect of the land, not a particular part of it, the children say.
Mafube Coal Mining
A right to bury at Graveyard 1 did not give the family a right to open a new grave at its homestead, Mafube says.
Simon Buta died, and his family sought to bury him on the farm where he had lived.
Mafube approached the Land Court for an urgent order preventing the burial on its land, and the court granted an interim interdict that evening.
After the planned burial at Graveyard 1 was prevented, the family buried Buta at their homestead.
The Land Court ordered the family to exhume Buta’s remains.
- Deceased
- Simon Buta
- Farm location
- Mpumalanga
- Land owner
- Mafube Coal Mining
- Interim interdict
- Granted on 15 March 2024
- Exhumation order
- Granted on 18 July 2024
- Appeal court
- Constitutional Court
What people are saying
The right is in respect of the land itself and not a particular portion of it,
A right to bury in Graveyard 1, if it existed, was not a right to a new grave at the family homestead,