Politics · Germany · 1 hr ago
Klose says Berlin coalition with the Left would be difficult if Emde stays in its group
On an ntv talk show, SPD lawmaker Annika Klose discussed a possible Berlin coalition with the Left and whether it could go ahead if Vanessa Emde stays in the party’s parliamentary group.
Emde is a member of the Left, and the group has faced calls for her to leave; the SPD leadership has also said she should give up her seat.
Asked whether she would oppose the coalition if Emde remained, Klose said it would be very difficult, but did not give an unequivocal yes or no.
She said she wanted to see whether the Left’s group leadership could enforce its position, and argued that the decision should not depend on one person.
The issue matters because the SPD’s member vote is due to start on January 4, and Klose said members see Emde’s status as a condition for joining a coalition.
The coalition talks are expected to be over by then, and Klose’s current leaning is against joining if Emde stays.
SPD lawmaker Annika Klose said forming a Berlin coalition with the Left would be very difficult if Vanessa Emde remained in the Left parliamentary group.
Klose said she was inclined to oppose the coalition in that situation, while expressing strong support for a red-red-green coalition.
She said the decision depended partly on whether the Left parliamentary group’s leadership could enforce its position on Emde.
CDU lawmaker Pascal Reddig argued that the problem extended beyond Emde and said the Left could not be governed with in Berlin.
A Berlin SPD membership vote is due to start on January 4, after coalition negotiations are expected to have concluded.
- Who
- SPD lawmaker Annika Klose and CDU lawmaker Pascal Reddig discussed the prospect of a Berlin coalition with the Left.
- What
- Klose said such a coalition would be very difficult if Vanessa Emde remained in the Left parliamentary group. Reddig opposed governing with the Left.
- When
- The discussion was broadcast on Monday evening; the article was published on November 17, 2026.
- Where
- Berlin was the focus of the coalition discussion, which took place on an ntv talk show.
- Why
- The discussion centered on whether Emde would remain in the Left parliamentary group and whether its leadership could enforce its position.
Annika Klose
Pascal Reddig
Coalition with the Left
Annika Klose
Klose said she strongly supported a red-red-green coalition but that it would be very difficult if Emde stayed in the group.
Pascal Reddig
Reddig said the Left could not be governed with in Berlin.
Emde and the Left group
Annika Klose
Klose said the issue was a structural question about whether the group’s leadership could enforce its position.
Pascal Reddig
Reddig said the problem was not only Emde, but the wider Left parliamentary group.
Klose and Reddig discussed a possible Berlin coalition with the Left on an ntv talk show.
The Berlin SPD membership vote is due to begin, after coalition negotiations are expected to have concluded.
- Klose
- SPD lawmaker
- Reddig
- CDU lawmaker
- Emde
- Vanessa Emde, a member of the Left parliamentary group
- Membership vote
- Berlin SPD vote due to start January 4
- Article publication
- November 17, 2026
What people are saying
It would be very difficult if she stayed in.
Yes, broadly speaking, although I strongly support red-red-green.
In Berlin, you simply cannot govern with the Left.