Politics · Switzerland · 9 hrs ago
Swiss villages divided over 13th pension, wary of VAT increase
Schmitten and Isenthal took opposite sides in Switzerland’s 2024 vote on a 13th payment from the AHV, the state pension system.
In Schmitten, in the canton of Graubünden, 81.63% supported the proposal, while in Isenthal, in the canton of Uri, 80.5% voted against it.
Some in Schmitten said the extra payment would help people with low pensions or no occupational pension, while Isenthal residents said they did not need it or worried about higher costs.
The government plans to fund the extra payments with a VAT increase, a rise in the tax on goods and services.
Residents in both villages expressed doubts about who would bear the cost, including some who had supported the pension proposal.
Others said the additional pension must be paid for if the state is to meet growing needs.
The debate now centres on how to pay for the pension, with opinions about the funding less divided than opinions on the original proposal.
Schmitten strongly backed Switzerland’s 13th AHV pension, while Isenthal strongly rejected it in the March 2024 vote.
Residents in both villages are now wary of a proposed value-added tax increase to fund the extra pension.
Schmitten’s support for the pension was linked by residents to ageing, outmigration and limited retirement income.
Some Isenthal residents questioned the need for the pension, while others said it should be funded if public needs increase.
Views within both villages are not uniform on either the pension or how to pay for it.
- Who
- Residents of Schmitten and Isenthal, two Swiss mountain villages.
- What
- The villages differ sharply over the 13th AHV pension, while residents in both express concern about a proposed value-added tax increase to fund it.
- When
- The pension vote took place in March 2024. SRF reported on residents’ views on November 17, 2026.
- Where
- Schmitten in Graubünden and Isenthal in Uri, Switzerland.
- Why
- Schmitten residents cited limited retirement income and the village’s ageing population; some Isenthal residents questioned the pension or the cost of financing it.
Schmitten supporters of the 13th AHV pension
Isenthal opponents of the 13th AHV pension
Pension vote
Schmitten supporters of the 13th AHV pension
Schmitten approved the initiative with 81.63 percent.
Isenthal opponents of the 13th AHV pension
Isenthal rejected it with 80.5 percent.
Reasons
Schmitten supporters of the 13th AHV pension
Residents cited low pensions, a lack of occupational pension coverage and the village’s ageing population.
Isenthal opponents of the 13th AHV pension
Some residents said they did not need the extra pension or questioned the need for people to retire earlier.
Funding
Schmitten supporters of the 13th AHV pension
Residents expressed concern about the proposed value-added tax increase.
Isenthal opponents of the 13th AHV pension
Residents also expressed concern about the proposed value-added tax increase.
Schmitten approved the 13th AHV pension initiative with 81.63 percent, while Isenthal rejected it with 80.5 percent.
SRF reported that residents in both villages were wary of a proposed value-added tax increase to fund the pension.
- Schmitten vote
- 81.63 percent supported the initiative
- Isenthal vote
- 80.5 percent rejected the initiative
- Schmitten population
- Around 250 residents
- Isenthal population
- 450 residents
- Funding proposal
- A value-added tax increase
- Reporting date
- November 17, 2026
What people are saying
Financing is another problem.
I would be in favour of everyone working until 67. People are living longer.
We know what it means when value-added tax rises by a few tenths. That also means paying a lot more.
I voted yes. But maybe that was a mistake.