2 weeks ago
Shah offers Parliament debate as Opposition demands firing answer
A group of students in India was very upset because their exam papers were leaked, and they wanted the education minister to quit.
When they walked from a place called Jantar Mantar to the Parliament building to complain, the police used force, and some students got hurt.
Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi asked a very important question: who told the police to do that?
Home Minister Amit Shah said he was ready to talk about it in Parliament, but only if the Opposition wrote a letter to the Speaker by 3 o'clock.
The Opposition said no, because they thought making them write a letter was just another way to avoid answering.
They wanted a straight answer, not a long discussion.
Amit Shah then wrote a letter to the Speaker himself, asking for a discussion.
Other leaders, like Priyanka Gandhi Vadra and Akhilesh Yadav, also said the government should be responsible for what happened.
In the end, the two sides could not agree, and the Parliament session was almost over.
Home Minister Amit Shah offered a full Parliament discussion on the students' protest if the Opposition submitted a written request to the Speaker by 3pm, promising to answer every point from 3pm to 3pm.
Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi rejected the offer, demanding a direct answer to one question: who ordered the firing on students during the July 20 march from Jantar Mantar to Parliament.
Students were protesting to demand Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan's resignation over exam paper leaks and other lapses.
The Opposition alleged police used lathi-charge, pellet guns and AK-47 fire, blinding one student and shooting another in the ear, and demanded accountability.
After the rejection, Shah wrote to Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla urging consultation, while parliamentary affairs minister Kiren Rijiju accused the Opposition of running away from debate.
Samajwadi Party chief Akhilesh Yadav called the government's time limit on the discussion undemocratic.
- Who
- Home Minister Amit Shah, Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi, Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan, student protesters, and Opposition leaders including Priyanka Gandhi Vadra and Akhilesh Yadav.
- What
- A political standoff over a proposed Parliament discussion on police action against student protesters demanding the education minister's resignation over exam paper leaks.
- Where
- New Delhi — Parliament, with the protest march from Jantar Mantar to Parliament.
- When
- Wednesday, with just one day left in the monsoon session; the student march occurred on July 20.
- Why
- The Opposition wanted accountability for the alleged police firing and excesses against student protesters, while the government proposed a conditional debate it said the Opposition blocked.
Government / Home Ministry
Opposition Parties
Format of the Debate
Government / Home Ministry
The government is ready for a full discussion on all aspects if the Opposition submits a written request to the Speaker by 3pm, within a 3pm-to-3pm window, and Shah will answer every point.
Opposition Parties
The condition and time limit are 'undemocratic'; the Opposition wants a direct statement and answer on who ordered the firing, not a constrained discussion.
Accountability for Police Action
Government / Home Ministry
The government has nothing to hide; a discussion should be held first, after which the home minister will reply to every point raised.
Opposition Parties
Amit Shah must say who ordered the firing, lathi-charge and pellet guns; if he gave the order he should resign as culpable, and if he did not, he should resign as incompetent.
Attendance in Parliament
Government / Home Ministry
Shah has been coming to Parliament regularly but the Opposition blocked proceedings in both Houses; parliamentary affairs minister Kiren Rijiju said the Opposition ran away from a debate.
Opposition Parties
Shah was 'missing' for 20 days, avoided piloting bills listed in his name, and his last-minute offer was a desperate attempt to evade accountability.
Key facts
- Home Minister
- Amit Shah
- Leader of Opposition
- Rahul Gandhi
- Protest demand
- Resignation of Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan over exam paper leaks
- Protest date
- July 20
- Protest route
- Jantar Mantar to Parliament
- Government's offer
- Discussion from 3pm to 3pm if Opposition wrote to the Speaker by 3pm
- Alleged police action
- Lathi-charge, pellet guns and AK-47 firing; one student blinded, another shot in the ear
- Monsoon session
- One day left; two bills listed in Shah's name were not piloted by him
Quotes
Priyanka Gandhi Vadra
Member of Parliament, Indian National Congress
“"We are not interested in listening to Amit Shah’s imagination. We want to know who shot the students, who blinded one student, who shot another in the ear, and who ordered the lathi-charge on students."”
telegraphindia.com
“"Let them submit a letter to the Speaker by 3pm. We are ready for a discussion on all aspects from 3pm today till 3pm tomorrow. I will sit in the House, listen to everyone and respond to every point."”
telegraphindia.com
Sources
Related news
Shah Offers Debate on Student Crackdown, Gandhi Demands Resignation
Amit Shah Offers NEET Protest Debate; Rahul Gandhi Demands Answers
Govt Ready for Parliament Discussion on NEET Protest, Shah Says
Amit Shah ready for detailed response as Parliament logjam persists
Rahul Gandhi rejects Amit Shah's discussion offer on student protests
Shah Offers NEET Debate, Opposition Demands Answers on Protests
India, Bangladesh Seek Deeper Parliamentary and People-to-People Ties
Twenty NCPI MPs Seek Extension in TMC Disqualification Case
Indian Statistical Institute Bill Sent To Parliamentary Panel
Abhishek Banerjee Rules Out TMC Return for ‘Traitors’
Nepal Thanks India as Flood Relief Reaches Amid Rising Toll
