8 months ago
Shilpa Shinde Returns to Bhabiji Ghar Par Hai 2.0
Shilpa Shinde, who is returning to the TV show Bhabiji Ghar Par Hai 2.0, made some comments about another actress, Shubhangi Atre, who played the same role for ten years.
Shilpa said that not everyone can do comedy and that acting in a role that was already played by someone else is hard.
Some people, including actor Sourabh Raj Jain, didn't like her comments.
They said it's not right for Shilpa to comment on Shubhangi's talent, especially since Shubhangi was so popular in the role.
This has started a big discussion about how to handle changes in casting in TV shows.
Shilpa Shinde is returning to the TV show Bhabiji Ghar Par Hai 2.0 after a decade.
She made comments about Shubhangi Atre's acting and comedy talent in an interview.
Shilpa acknowledged Shubhangi's talent but said not everyone can do comedy.
Some audience members and actors, including Sourabh Raj Jain, criticized Shilpa's comments.
The controversy highlights the sensitivities around casting changes in TV series.
- Who
- Shilpa Shinde, Shubhangi Atre, Sourabh Raj Jain
- What
- Controversy over comments about acting and comedy talent
- Where
- India
- When
- Before the rollout of Bhabiji Ghar Par Hai 2.0
- Why
- Shilpa Shinde's comments on Shubhangi Atre's acting and comedy talent
Shilpa Shinde's Perspective
Critics' Perspective
Comments on Comedy Talent
Shilpa Shinde's Perspective
Shilpa acknowledged Shubhangi's talent but stated that not everyone can do comedy, implying the difficulty of stepping into an established role.
Critics' Perspective
Critics, including Sourabh Raj Jain, found Shilpa's comments disrespectful and inappropriate, especially given Shubhangi's popularity and success in the role.
Key facts
- Actress
- Shilpa Shinde
- Show
- Bhabiji Ghar Par Hai 2.0
- Role
- Angoori Bhabhi
- Original Actress
- Shubhangi Atre
- Critic
- Sourabh Raj Jain
Quotes
Shilpa Shinde
Actress known for her role as Angoori Bhabhi in the TV show Bhabiji Ghar Par Hain
“At that time, every show except ours had flopped. So, these people wanted to exert control on our show. They tried to gain publicity for the channel through me. They sent me to a TV award ceremony in my character’s outfit! Whether from the channel or other authorities, the bottomline was to control me.”
news18.com
“Even after giving everything to the show for a year, I was completely sidelined. A lot of misunderstandings were created. I took this experience as a lesson, it showed me the real [nature] of people. I didn’t have any complaints with my co-stars. There were people claiming that I had left Bhabiji… for another show. No one knew the reality”
news18.com
Sources
Shilpa Shinde’s Statement on Shubhangi Atre Leads to New Brouhaha; Sourabh Raj Jain Brands it ‘Lacking Basic Decency’
Shilpa Shinde On Returning As Angoori In Bhabiji Ghar Par Hain 2.0: ‘Difficult To Make People Laugh’
Shilpa Shinde Recalls Why She Left Bhabiji Ghar Par Hain: 'These People Wanted To Exert Control'
