Archive · 11 Oct 2026
ICE Defends Bronx Shooting as Mamdani Demands End to Operations
An ICE officer shot Oscar Belgal during an attempt to arrest him in the Bronx.
A five-year-old child was in Belgal’s car, but officials said the child was not physically hurt.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani said early reports indicated that officers surrounded the car before firing.
ICE official Marcos Charles gave a different account, saying Belgal drove toward officers and hit two government vehicles.
Federal officials said the officer fired because officers believed they were in danger.
The shooting is being investigated, and video from the encounter has been released by the NYPD, while officials said ICE body-camera footage would follow.
Mamdani wants ICE operations to end in New York City.
Federal officials defended the operation and argued that sanctuary policies make enforcement more dangerous.
Protests against ICE took place after the shooting.
An ICE officer shot Oscar Belgal, 28, in the neck during an arrest operation in Marble Hill, the Bronx, around 4 p.m. on Thursday, October 8.
A five-year-old child was in Belgal’s car; officials said the child was physically unharmed and was later located with a family member.
ICE official Marcos Charles said Belgal accelerated toward officers and struck two government vehicles; Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s early account said agents surrounded the car before firing.
Video released by the NYPD showed Belgal handcuffed beside a car as officers tended to him; federal officials said ICE body-camera footage would also be released.
Mamdani called for ICE operations to end in New York City, while federal officials defended the shooting and criticized sanctuary policies; protests followed.
- Who
- Oscar Belgal was shot by an ICE officer; a five-year-old child was in his car.
- What
- An ICE arrest operation ended in a shooting, with differing accounts of what happened before the officer fired.
- When
- Around 4 p.m. on Thursday, October 8; federal officials defended the shooting on Friday, October 9.
- Where
- Marble Hill, in the Bronx borough of New York City.
- Why
- ICE said it was attempting to arrest Belgal. Federal officials said he drove toward officers and struck government vehicles; the full circumstances remain under investigation.
Local criticism and calls for accountability
Federal defense of the operation
What happened before the shooting
Local criticism and calls for accountability
Mamdani said early reports indicated that agents surrounded Belgal and the child in the car before firing. Local officials and advocates sought a transparent investigation and video.
Federal defense of the operation
ICE official Marcos Charles said Belgal refused to exit, accelerated toward officers, and struck two government vehicles. Federal officials said officers believed they were in danger.
ICE enforcement in New York
Local criticism and calls for accountability
Mamdani demanded an end to ICE enforcement actions in the city, and protesters called for ICE to leave New York.
Federal defense of the operation
Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin and ICE criticized sanctuary policies, arguing that limits on local cooperation make arrests more unpredictable and dangerous.
Evidence and accountability
Local criticism and calls for accountability
Governor Kathy Hochul and advocates called for a full account, investigation, and release of relevant footage. Legal Aid also called for accountability and an investigation by city prosecutors.
Federal defense of the operation
Federal officials said the incident remained under investigation. The NYPD released its body-worn camera video, and Mullin said ICE body-camera footage would eventually be released.
- Person shot
- Oscar Belgal, 28
- Location and time
- Marble Hill, the Bronx, around 4 p.m. on October 8
- Injury
- ICE official Marcos Charles said Belgal suffered a superficial wound to his neck.
- Child in car
- A five-year-old was in the car; officials said the child was physically unharmed and later located with a family member.
- Federal account
- ICE official Marcos Charles said Belgal accelerated toward officers and struck two ICE vehicles; officials said officers believed they were in danger.
- Video
- The NYPD released body-worn camera video showing Belgal handcuffed beside a car; federal officials said ICE body-camera footage would also be released.
- Political response
- Mayor Zohran Mamdani called for ICE operations to end in the city; Governor Kathy Hochul called for a full and transparent account.
- Protests
- Protests against ICE took place after the shooting, including gatherings in the Bronx and a march in Manhattan.
Sources
Mamdani Says Child Was in Car When ICE Agent Shot New York Man
'Will Not Stand by While ICE Agents Terrorise Our Communities': NYC Mayor Mamdani as Anti-ICE Protests Erupt
ICE Officials Shot At New York Man Because They Felt Unsafe: Senior Officer
ICE agents shoot New York City man in car with 5-year-old child present, says mayor Zohran Mamdani - Telegraph India
New York protests erupt as Trump administration defends ICE shooting
ICE agents shoot man in New York: What we know and don’t know
Zohran Mamdani Calls Trump, Says ICE Agents Shot Man In Car With Child
Man shot during encounter with federal agents in New York, ICE reportedly involved
New York City man shot in car with child present by ICE agents, mayor says
US immigration chiefs defend shooting of New York man, attack ‘sanctuary’ policies