40 mins ago
Pro Ref Admits VAR Error in Manchester Derby Goal
Manchester City played Manchester United in a football match at Old Trafford.
Erling Haaland scored a goal that gave Manchester City a 1-0 win.
The referee first said the goal was offside, which means the player was too far forward.
VAR checked the decision and decided Haaland himself was onside.
However, City teammate Enzo Fernandez was also in an offside position and tried to head the ball.
Pro Ref later said VAR should have considered whether Fernandez affected the play.
The refereeing organization called this a mistake.
Manchester United manager Michael Carrick was very unhappy about the decision.
Pro Ref has contacted Manchester United and will examine what happened.
Pro Ref said VAR wrongly allowed Erling Haaland’s goal in Manchester City’s 1-0 derby win.
Haaland’s strike was initially ruled offside but overturned after a VAR review.
The review found Haaland onside but failed to consider teammate Enzo Fernandez’s potential impact.
Manchester United manager Michael Carrick strongly criticized the decision after the defeat.
Pro Ref contacted Manchester United and said it would review the incident.
- Who
- Manchester City, Manchester United, Erling Haaland, Enzo Fernandez, Pro Ref, and Manchester United manager Michael Carrick.
- What
- Pro Ref acknowledged that VAR made an error by allowing Haaland’s decisive goal to stand.
- Where
- Old Trafford in Manchester.
- When
- Sunday, during the Manchester derby; Pro Ref issued its acknowledgment afterward.
- Why
- VAR determined Haaland was onside but failed to consider the likely impact of Fernandez, who was in an offside position.
Manchester United’s Position
Pro Ref’s Explanation
Whether the goal should have stood
Manchester United’s Position
Manchester United argued that the goal should not have been allowed because Enzo Fernandez was offside and may have influenced the play.
Pro Ref’s Explanation
Pro Ref said Haaland was correctly found to be onside, but VAR should have recommended an on-field review because Fernandez’s likely impact was not considered.
Assessment of the officiating
Manchester United’s Position
Michael Carrick said he could not understand how the officials and VAR failed to make the correct decision despite the additional review process.
Pro Ref’s Explanation
Pro Ref characterized the incident as an error of judgment and said it would review what happened.
Key facts
- Match result
- Manchester City defeated Manchester United 1-0.
- Decisive scorer
- Erling Haaland scored on the hour mark.
- Initial decision
- The goal was initially disallowed for offside.
- VAR decision
- VAR overturned the on-field ruling after finding Haaland onside.
- VAR error
- Pro Ref said VAR failed to recognize the likely impact of Enzo Fernandez’s offside position.
- Follow-up
- Pro Ref contacted Manchester United and said the incident would be reviewed.
- Manager reaction
- Michael Carrick expressed strong frustration with the decision.
Quotes
Pro Ref
Refereeing body that reviewed the Manchester derby incident
“Contact has been made with Manchester United this evening to acknowledge what we deem is an error of judgement. A review of the incident will take place.”
rediff.com
“The on-field decision was offside against Erling Haaland – that was checked by VAR and he was found to be in an onside position.”
rediff.com
Michael Carrick
Manchester United manager reacting to the controversial decision
“I just don't get it, I really don't get it, I can't understand how we're trying to help referees, putting so many layers behind them, so many people, bodies and screens, and they can't make the right decision.”
rediff.com









