7 months ago
Controversy Over Supreme Court Remarks on Stray Dogs
Animal rights groups are worried about some things the Supreme Court said recently.
They think the court's words might make people treat dogs and the people who take care of them badly.
The groups wrote to the Chief Justice to say that the court's remarks could lead to unfair treatment and violence.
They mentioned some sad things that have happened to dogs, like many being killed or hurt.
The groups want the court to be careful with its words and to make sure everyone is treated fairly and kindly.
Maneka Gandhi also criticized the court, saying it created an atmosphere of hate.
The Supreme Court, however, says it was serious when it talked about making dog feeders responsible for attacks, not being sarcastic.
Activists argue that the court's remarks could lead to more violence against dogs and feeders, and they want better programs to control the dog population.
Animal rights organizations have asked members to write to the Chief Justice of India expressing concerns over the Supreme Court's remarks on January 13.
Activists believe the court's remarks risk framing community care as culpability and overlook statutory failures of the state and local authorities.
There has been an escalation in cruelty against community dogs and violence against feeders, particularly women, following the court's remarks.
Specific incidents reported include the killing of 500 dogs in Telangana, 40 dogs at Symbiosis International University, 24 dogs relocated in MAHE Udupi, and a puppy sexually assaulted and killed in Bangalore.
Maneka Gandhi criticized the Supreme Court for creating an atmosphere of hate and disservice to India with its remarks.
- Who
- Animal rights organizations, feeders, particularly women, the Supreme Court, and Maneka Gandhi
- What
- Controversy over Supreme Court remarks on stray dogs and subsequent violence against dogs and feeders
- Where
- India, with specific incidents in Telangana, Hyderabad, Udupi, and Bangalore
- When
- After Supreme Court remarks on January 13
- Why
- To address perceived compromise of natural justice, judicial neutrality, and scientific reasoning, and to prevent violence against dogs and feeders
Key facts
- Date of Supreme Court Remarks
- January 13
- Incidents Reported
- 500 dogs killed in Telangana, 40 dogs killed at Symbiosis International University, 24 dogs relocated in MAHE Udupi, puppy sexually assaulted and killed in Bangalore
- Constitutional Articles Cited
- Articles 14, 15, 21, and 51A(g)
- Request to CJI
- Issuance of appropriate guidance for judicial restraint and meaningful hearing
- Primary Concern
- Escalation in cruelty against community dogs and violence against feeders
- Supreme Court's Stance
- The court emphasized the seriousness of its remarks on making dog feeders responsible for stray dog attacks.
- Animal Welfare Activists' Stance
- Activists argue for the implementation of effective sterilization programs and the formation of an expert committee.
- Maneka Gandhi's Remarks
- Criticized the Supreme Court for creating an atmosphere of hate and disservice to India.
Timeline
The Supreme Court's suo motu notice of news over a dog bite leading to rabies likely sparked their recent consideration of a case involving a woman seeking compensation for a dog bite.
The Supreme Court's consideration of a case involving a woman seeking Rs 20 lakh compensation for a dog bite likely sparked their recent remarks about stray dogs and potential compensation orders.
The Supreme Court's recent remarks about stray dogs, including a potential order for states to pay heavy compensation for dog-bite incidents, likely sparked concern among animal rights groups.
Animal rights groups expressed concern that recent Supreme Court remarks could incite violence against dogs and their caretakers, prompting them to write to the Chief Justice for clarification.
Quotes
SAFI representative
Representative of the Stray Animal Foundation of India
“We visited the village and enquired with the residents. They told us that more than 100 dogs were killed within a span of two days by injecting them.”
deccanchronicle.com
“People are misunderstanding Supreme Court orders and taking the law into their own hands.”
deccanchronicle.com
Yacharam sub-inspector Uyyala Madhu
Sub-inspector of Yacharam police station
“Right now it does not appear to be 100 dogs (at Yacharam). Based on the information available, the number could be around 32 to 40, or at most 45. We need to confirm the figure.”
deccanchronicle.com
“Our primary objective is to trace the dogs and verify the records. We will have more info soon.”
deccanchronicle.com
Dr Mini Aravindan
Senior Director of Veterinary Affairs at PETA India
“The convulsions, muscle stiffening and frothing at the mouth indicate that the substance affected the central nervous system, lungs and heart. This kind of response points to intense pain and does not align with recognised veterinary euthanasia protocols.”
deccanchronicle.com
Sources
'Kasab didin't...' SC irked by Maneka Gandhi's criticism over stray dog order
SC Says Maneka Gandhi Has Committed 'Contempt of Court' With Her Remarks On Stray Dogs Order - What Did She Say?
‘Contempt of court’: Supreme Court irked by Maneka Gandhi's criticism of its order in stray dog case
Animal Rights Groups Write To CJI Over Supreme Court Remarks, Warn Of Violence Against Dogs
40 Dogs Allegedly Killed at Symbiosis Law College, Third Mass Culling Case in Telangana
Top Court Slams Maneka Gandhi For Stray Dogs Remark, Flags "Body Language"
'She committed contempt but...': Supreme Court on Maneka Gandhi's criticism of stray dogs case order
‘Have you heard her podcast?’: SC loses patience with Maneka Gandhi over stray dog remarks, flags contempt
‘Contempt of court’: SC irked by Maneka Gandhi’s criticism of its order in stray dog case
Our magnanimity that no action taken against Maneka Gandhi despite contempt of court, says SC
SC slams Maneka Gandhi for criticism of orders on stray dogs, says she committed contempt
Supreme Court Pulls Up Maneka Gandhi for “Reckless” Comments on Dog Menace Orders
Animal Welfare Organisations Flag Mass Killing of Stray Dogs in Telangana
