Archive · 9 Aug 2025
Supreme Court Drops Criticism of High Court Judge
The Supreme Court changed its mind about some critical comments it made about a judge, Prashant Kumar.
They had previously mentioned that the judge allowed a criminal case to go forward in a civil matter.
The Supreme Court's goal was to ensure respect for the court system as a whole, not to embarrass Judge Kumar.
They clarified that their initial order was about maintaining the dignity of the courts and justice.
Supreme Court removed its criticism of Allahabad High Court Judge Prashant Kumar.
The criticism stemmed from Judge Kumar allowing criminal proceedings in a civil dispute.
The initial order had requested the Chief Justice to reassign the case.
The Supreme Court stated its intent was to maintain judicial dignity.
The reversal aimed to clarify that there was no intent to embarrass the judge.
- Who
- Supreme Court, Allahabad High Court judge Prashant Kumar.
- What
- The Supreme Court withdrew its criticism of Allahabad High Court judge Prashant Kumar.
- When
- The reversal happened on Friday.
- Where
- Supreme Court.
- Why
- The Supreme Court's action was taken to uphold judicial dignity.
Initial Order
Revised Order
Main Points of Contention
Initial Order
Concerned with the Judge allowing criminal proceedings in a civil dispute.
Revised Order
Emphasized the importance of judicial dignity.
- Court
- Supreme Court
- Subject
- Allahabad High Court Judge Prashant Kumar
- Action
- Criticism Removed
- Original Concern
- Criminal proceedings in civil case
- Reason
- To maintain judicial dignity
Sources
Supreme Court relists case where it took judge off criminal cases after 13 Allahabad HC judges protest
Allahabad High Court Judges Seek To Defy Top Court Over Judge-Criminal Cases Row
In letter to CJ, Allahabad HC judges seek full court meeting in Justice Prashant Kumar’s matter
Supreme Court Recalls Order Banning High Court Judge From Hearing Criminal Cases
SC deletes criticism of Allahabad HC judge's order
Supreme Court withdraws order removing Allahabad HC Judge from criminal roster
SC deletes observations it made while barring Allahabad High Court judge from hearing criminal cases
'Our Intention Was Not to Embarrass Allahabad HC Judge': SC Recalls 'Worst Order' Remark
13 Allahabad HC Judges Oppose SC Order Against Justice Prashant Kumar, Seek Full Court Meeting
SC deletes observation against Allahabad HC judge
SC removes criticism of Allahabad HC judge over order
After CJI Gavai's Request, Supreme Recalls Direction Barring Allahabad HC Judge From Hearing Criminal Cases
After protest by 13 Allahabad HC judges, SC rescinds bar on judge from hearing criminal cases
SC recalls its order against Allahabad HHC judge Justice Kumar after intervention of CJI Gavai
Allahabad HC bar welcomes SC decision to delete remarks against judge
SC withdraws order restricting Allahabad HC judge from hearing criminal cases
Remarks against Allahabad HC judge: SC deletes observations after CJI intervenes
Top Court Deletes Observation Against Allahabad High Court After Chief Justice BR Gavai's Intervention
CJI BR Gavai nudges, Supreme Court bench takes back order on Allahabad High Court judge - Telegraph India
