1 day ago
Swara Bhasker Revisits Padmaavat Jauhar Criticism Amid Online Backlash
Swara Bhasker talked again about a scene in the movie Padmaavat.
The scene shows Rani Padmavati and hundreds of women entering a fire during a war.
This act is called jauhar.
Swara said the scene could make rape survivors feel that they should have died instead of continuing to live.
She also disliked a shot showing a pregnant woman going toward the fire.
In 2018, she wrote a letter criticizing the movie after waiting five days to think about her response.
Some critics said she was disrespecting Rajput women and judging an old wartime practice by modern standards.
Swara replied that rape survivors have a right to live after rape.
Swara Bhasker renewed her criticism of Padmaavat’s climactic jauhar sequence at a Delhi event.
She questioned whether the scene could make rape survivors feel they should have died to preserve their honour.
Bhasker said a close-up of a pregnant woman approaching the pyre was especially disturbing.
She said she waited five days before writing her 2018 open letter to director Sanjay Leela Bhansali.
Her remarks prompted online criticism, with opponents accusing her of disrespecting Rajput women and overlooking the wartime context of jauhar.
- Who
- Actor Swara Bhasker, director Sanjay Leela Bhansali, and critics of Bhasker’s comments.
- What
- Bhasker revisited and defended her criticism of Padmaavat’s jauhar scene and her 2018 open letter.
- Where
- The event was held at the India International Centre in New Delhi, and the letter was published by The Wire.
- When
- She spoke at a Delhi event on August 31, 2026, according to one report; her open letter was published in 2018.
- Why
- Bhasker said the scene could imply that rape survivors should have died to preserve their honour, while critics said it represented a historical wartime choice that should be understood in context.
Bhasker’s Criticism
Critics’ Historical Defence
Message to survivors
Bhasker’s Criticism
Bhasker argued that depicting women choosing death to protect their honour could make rape survivors feel they did not deserve to live or had failed to be brave.
Critics’ Historical Defence
Critics said the film does not instruct contemporary rape survivors to die and that Bhasker was applying a modern interpretation to a historical story.
Meaning of jauhar
Bhasker’s Criticism
Bhasker objected to what she viewed as the glorification of jauhar and sati, emphasizing that women have the right to live after rape or the death of their husbands.
Critics’ Historical Defence
Critics described jauhar as a wartime decision during sieges intended to avoid capture, enslavement, forced conversion, and sexual violence.
Depiction of Rajput women
Bhasker’s Criticism
Bhasker said the sequence, especially the image of a pregnant woman, was problematic because it appeared to suggest that potential future victims should not be born.
Critics’ Historical Defence
Social-media critics accused her of insulting Rajput women and disregarding the circumstances and values associated with the historical tradition of jauhar.
Key facts
- Film
- Padmaavat, also referred to as Padmavat in some reports
- Director
- Sanjay Leela Bhansali
- Scene discussed
- A sequence depicting around 800 women committing jauhar
- Central question
- Whether rape should be viewed as the end of a woman’s life
- Specific image criticized
- A pregnant woman shown approaching the funeral pyre
- Original open letter
- Written and published in 2018 on The Wire
- Bhasker’s response
- She called the backlash “wild” and said rape survivors have a right to life after rape
Quotes
Swara Bhasker
Indian actress and critic of Padmaavat’s portrayal of Jauhar
“I'm watching this and it shows all these 800 women committing jauhar which is the story. Watching it I was thinking that 'God forbid, I was a rape survivor, what is this film telling me? I would feel like a coward. That I didn't kill myself to save my 'honour'.”
NDTV
freepressjournal.in
NDTV
wionews.com
“The context of your film is India in the 21stcentury; where five years ago, a girl was gang-raped brutally in the country’s capital inside a moving bus. She didn’t commit suicide because her honour had been desecrated, Sir. She fought her six rapists.”
wionews.com
Online commenters
Social-media users who criticized Swara Bhasker’s remarks
“Women who committed Jauhar were cowards”
wionews.com
“Bas news mein rehna hai.”
timesnownews.com
Sources
Swara Bhasker 2018 open letter to Sanjay Leela Bhansali: Felt 'reduced to vagina' after watching Padmaavat
"Is Rape End Of A Woman's Life?" Swara Bhasker Revisits Padmaavat Open Letter On Jauhar To Bhansali
'So Many People Are Triggered...': Swara Bhasker Hits Back At Trolls Over 'Problematic' Padmaavat Jauhar Scene Remark
Swara Bhasker REACTS After Padmaavat Jauhar Scene Remark Faces Criticism: Wild So Many People Are Triggered
Swara Bhaskar criticises Jauhar scene of Padmavat during IIC event
'Rape Survivors Have A Right To Life': Swara Bhasker Reacts To 'Wild' Backlash Over Padmaavat Remark
Swara Bhasker reacts to criticism over Padmaavat Jauhar scene remark: ‘Rape survivors have a right to life’
'Called Rajput women who chose fire over Khilji 'cowards': Swara Bhaskar slams Padmaavat, sparks massive backlash
Related news
Swara Bhasker Clarifies Padmaavat Jauhar Remarks Amid Backlash
Swara Bhasker Faces Backlash Over Padmaavat Jauhar Remarks
Swara Bhaskar Says Padmaavat Criticism Ruined Her Acting Career
Fahad Ahmad Defends Swara Bhasker Over Padmaavat Remark
Mahila Morcha Burns Banners Over Anasuya's Jai Shri Ram Comments
Madhya Pradesh BJP MLA’s ‘Maut Ka Samaan’ Remark Sparks Row
Jyoti Yadav’s Covid Book Challenges India’s Forced Forgetting
Journalism Fundamentals Seen as Key to Restoring Public Trust
Jaipur Class 12 Student Dies, Family Alleges Canteen Negligence
Kangana Ranaut Questions Bollywood's 'Love Affair' With Pakistan
