Archive · 20 Aug 2025
Might Makes Right: Justice and Authority
Imagine a rule where whoever is strongest gets to decide what's fair.
This idea, called 'might makes right,' says power matters more than what's truly just.
The article talks about how this can happen when people in charge, like government officials or the Election Commission, make decisions that seem unfair and disregard people's rights.
It criticizes the actions of authorities that may make it harder for people to vote, questioning whether they are treating everyone fairly.
The main point is that justice should not be about who has the most power, but about ensuring everyone's rights are protected.
The article discusses the concept of 'might makes right,' where power dictates justice, and the potential erosion of rights by those in authority.
It references historical context, including Thucydides' writings and Arthur Desmond's book, to explain the origins of the concept.
The author critiques actions by authorities, such as the Election Commission of India (EC), which they believe undermine the rights of the powerless.
The article questions the EC's procedures for voter identification and roll management.
The piece concludes with a call for justice and the protection of citizens' rights, referencing a Supreme Court interim order.
- Who
- The author, a former election commissioner, critiques actions by authorities.
- What
- An analysis of the concept 'might makes right' and its implications on justice and the potential abuse of power by authorities.
- When
- The article discusses the current issues and provides historical context from 416 BCE.
- Where
- The examples mentioned come from India, but the concept's origins are in ancient Greece.
- Why
- To highlight how those in positions of power can potentially undermine justice and citizen rights, urging for the protection of the powerless.
Those in Power
Citizens
Approach to Justice
Those in Power
Prioritize power and self-interest.
Citizens
Protect the rights of all citizens.
Exercise of Authority
Those in Power
Exercise unilateral authority.
Citizens
Uphold democratic principles.
- Concept Discussed
- 'Might Makes Right'
- Historical Reference
- Melian Dialogue (416 BCE)
- Book Mentioned
- Might is Right: Or the Survival of the Fittest
- Organization Criticized
- Election Commission of India (EC)
- Legal Action Mentioned
- Supreme Court Interim Order