Archive · 22 Aug 2025
Bills on Jailed Leaders Draw Criticism, Debate in India
New bills propose that if a Prime Minister, Chief Minister, or minister is in jail for more than a month, they can no longer hold their job.
Prime Minister Modi supports these bills, saying everyone should be treated the same under the law, and pointing to an example where someone was running the government from jail.
Other politicians have criticized the bills, with some accusing the government of trying to steal votes.
Government introduces bills to disqualify jailed PMs, CMs, and ministers.
PM Modi defends bills, citing accountability and equal treatment under the law.
Rahul Gandhi criticizes Modi for not addressing alleged vote stealing during Bihar visit.
Amit Shah alleges corruption by DMK, criticizing Stalin's opposition to the bills.
ADR report indicates 40% of chief ministers face criminal cases.
- Who
- PM Modi, Rahul Gandhi, Amit Shah, various chief ministers, and opposition parties.
- What
- Bills proposing disqualification of jailed PMs, CMs, and ministers.
- When
- Bills introduced recently, with Modi and Shah speaking on August 22, 2025.
- Where
- India
- Why
- To ensure accountability and prevent government from being run from jail.
Opposition Concerns
Government Stance
Rationale
Opposition Concerns
Bills violate constitution and compromise federalism, and could be misused.
Government Stance
Bills ensure accountability and prevent government from being run from jail; no one should be above the law.
Allegations
Opposition Concerns
Government is attempting to steal votes with the use of the Election Commission.
Government Stance
DMK led the most corrupt government in the country.
- Bill Objective
- Disqualify jailed PMs, CMs, and Ministers
- Trigger for Removal
- 30+ days in custody
- Key Proponent
- PM Modi
- Key Critic
- Opposition Parties
- Criticism Point
- Potential for misuse
- Supporting Argument
- Ensure Accountability
- CMs with Criminal Cases
- 12 out of 30
Sources
How Arvind Kejriwal Case Paved Way For Bill To Sack Jailed Chief Ministers
7 of 10 chief ministers facing serious criminal charges are from Opposition, election data show
Explained: What the three Bills introduced by Amit Shah mean for arrested PM, CMs, and ministers
Rajya Sabha MP Kapil Sibal Accuses Govt Of Targeting Opposition Leaders Through New Bills - VIDEO
We will make it an Act: G Kishan Reddy counters Oppn over Bill to sack jailed PMs, CMs
‘Attack on opposition’, Gehlot, Jully slam Bills for removal of PMs, CMs, ministers
Natural for Oppn with full of criminals to question law: Dharmendra Pradhan
'Nothing wrong with it': Prashant Kishor backs Centre's Bill on ministers in jail
Centre’s bill to remove jailed PMs, CMs, Ministers: From Arvind Kejriwal to Shibu Soren, key arrests in 5 years
Govt lacks numbers to pass bill on removal of ministers: Former Lok Sabha Secretary
MyVoice: Views of our readers 22nd Aug 2025
Immoral tool: Editorial on Constitution Amendment Bill and the threat of one-party police State
Saamna Slams Amit Shah Over Bill for Removal of PM, CMs
Kishan Reddy defends landmark constitutional amendment, slams opposition’s stance
Parliament Debate: Bills Accused Of Weaponising Law To Crush Opposition
"Why Should Governments Be Run From Jail?" PM On 'Sack Jailed Ministers' Bill
‘Govt Employees Lose Job After Arrest, Why Not PM, CMs?’: Modi Defends Bills To Sack Jailed Ministers
2 MLAs From Lalu Yadav's Party On Stage At PM Modi's Bihar Event, BJP Responds
'Corrupt will go to jail and their chair will also go': PM Modi defends bills to sack jailed ministers
Bills seeking to remove elected representatives on criminal charges badly conceived and drafted: Constitutional expert
PM defends 130th Amendment Bill at Bihar rally, says Opposition afraid of political fallout
Amit Shah accuses Opposition VP candidate Sudershan Reddy of ‘helping’ Naxalism, invokes Salwa Judum judgment
Citing Kejriwal's Case, Amit Shah Defends Bills To Sack Jailed Ministers: 'In Democracy...'
"If Arvind Kejriwal Had Resigned...": Amit Shah On Bills To Sack Jailed Ministers
CM Omar questions Bill allowing arrest of PM, CMs, ministers
If gov employees like peon have to resign on being jailed for 50 hrs, why not PM, CM & Ministers
40% of chief ministers face criminal cases: ADR
PM did not utter a word on ‘vote chori’ during visit to Bihar: Rahul Gandhi