Archive · 20 May 2025
Criminal Case Recommended Against Doctor For Patient Transfer
Imagine a doctor who was supposed to help a sick person but instead sent them to a private hospital where he also worked.
This doctor allegedly refused to treat a woman with burns and sent her to a different hospital where she was treated.
The woman's family said he threatened her and charged a lot of money.
Now, a special group wants the doctor to be punished and the family to receive money.
They also said that other hospital staff members should also pay.
This is because the group believes the doctor and others were responsible for what happened to the patient.
The doctor could face criminal charges and lose his job.
SHRC recommended criminal case against a doctor for allegedly forcing a patient to a private hospital.
The doctor allegedly refused to treat a burn victim and sent her to a private hospital where he practiced.
The SHRC recommended ₹50 lakh compensation for the woman's husband and the doctor to pay ₹40 lakh.
The Directorate of Medical and Rural Health Services found most allegations against the doctor to be true.
The incident occurred in 2018, and the Commission held the doctor responsible for the woman's death.
- Who
- Dr. C. Prabakar, a government doctor, is the central figure, along with the woman and her husband.
- What
- The SHRC recommended a criminal case and compensation after a doctor allegedly forced a patient to a private hospital.
- When
- The incident occurred on November 27, 2018.
- Where
- Kovilpatti in Thoothukudi district, Tamil Nadu.
- Why
- The SHRC aims to address alleged medical misconduct and ensure accountability for patient care.
SHRC's Findings
Doctor's Possible Defense
Justification of Actions
SHRC's Findings
The SHRC and the Directorate found the doctor responsible for the woman's death due to the alleged actions of transferring her to the private hospital and providing inadequate care.
Doctor's Possible Defense
The doctor might argue that the private hospital offered better care or that the patient's condition required specialized treatment not available at the government facility.
Consequences
SHRC's Findings
The SHRC recommended the doctor be dismissed from government service.
Doctor's Possible Defense
The doctor might claim all actions were appropriate for patient care.
- Total Compensation Recommended
- ₹50 lakh
- Doctor's Financial Liability
- ₹40 lakh
- Date of Incident
- November 27, 2018
- State
- Tamil Nadu
- Doctor Involved
- Dr. C. Prabakar
- Location of Incident
- Kovilpatti