Archive · 9 Aug 2025
Taxable Gains vs. Real Profit: Reddit Post Sparks ITR Debate
Imagine you made some money trading stocks.
You made about ₹21,000.
However, the taxman thinks you made more, around ₹1 lakh, because of how they count the money.
This is because some of your trades were 'intraday,' meaning you bought and sold them on the same day.
The tax rules say you can't use the money you lost in intraday trading to reduce what you owe on other gains.
So, even though you only profited a little, you have to pay taxes as if you earned much more from the stock market.
This confuses people, but it's how the rules work.
A Reddit user reported a significant difference between realized profit and taxable gains in ITR filing.
The user's realized profit was ₹21,600, but the taxable gain was ₹1,03,297.57, as per their CA.
The discrepancy is due to how intraday trading losses are treated under income tax laws.
Intraday losses cannot be offset against short-term or long-term capital gains.
Experts confirm this tax treatment, with losses carried forward for future intraday gains.
- Who
- A Reddit user ('anoopdreams'), CAs, and Abhishek Soni, CEO of Tax2Win.
- What
- A Reddit user inquired about the difference between realized profit and taxable gain during ITR filing for stock market trading.
- When
- Ahead of the September 15th ITR filing deadline.
- Where
- Online, specifically on Reddit and reported by Mint.
- Why
- To understand why taxable gains were significantly higher than realized profits due to tax laws regarding intraday trading.
Taxpayer's View
Tax Authorities/Experts
Discrepancy
Taxpayer's View
Confused and surprised by the high taxable gains compared to actual profit.
Tax Authorities/Experts
Financial advisors and tax laws.
- Realized Profit
- ₹21,600
- Taxable Gain
- ₹1,03,297.57
- Intraday Loss
- ₹81,682.80
- Tax Treatment
- Intraday losses cannot offset capital gains.
- Losses Treatment
- Intraday losses can be carried forward.
- Source
- Reddit post and Mint report