Archive · 24 May 2025
Internet Divided Over Indian-Made Manhole Cover in Seattle
People online are talking about why manhole covers in Seattle are made in India.
Some wonder why, while others explain that India has been making these covers for a long time because it's cheaper.
A 2007 report from the New York Times said that the covers are 20 to 60 percent cheaper than those made in America, due to the lack of environmental standards.
The debate highlights concerns about job displacement.
Some are critical of the practice, viewing it as a sign of economic decline, while others acknowledge the cost factors.
It's a topic that's sparked discussion about globalization and its impacts on different countries and people.
A photo of an Indian-made manhole cover in Seattle sparked online discussion.
Some users questioned why the city sources manhole covers from India.
Cast iron for manhole covers has been sourced from India for decades.
The cost of the covers is 20-60% less than American made, according to a 2007 NYT report.
Debate includes views on job displacement and economic impact.
- Who
- Internet users, city of Seattle, manufacturers.
- What
- Online discussion regarding the origin of Seattle manhole covers.
- When
- Ongoing, with past reports from 2007.
- Where
- Seattle, with manufacturing in India.
- Why
- Due to lower costs.
Concerns about Job displacement
Acknowledging cost benefits
Viewpoint
Concerns about Job displacement
Concerned about job displacement
Acknowledging cost benefits
Recognizing cheaper cost
- Location of Manhole Cover
- Seattle
- Origin of Manhole Cover
- India
- Report on issue
- 2007 New York Times
- Cost Difference
- 20-60% cheaper than American-made