9 months ago
Dispute Over Charity Flat Allotment in Parsi Community
There's a big argument among the leaders of the Bombay Parsi Punchayet (BPP) about giving a special flat to the son of a famous police officer.
Some leaders say the son doesn't qualify because he lives outside India and might make too much money.
Others think the BPP should be kinder because the family has helped the community and the country.
The vote was tied, so the chairman had to decide.
The leaders who disagreed made a public statement, and now the BPP is asking the community for their opinions.
The chairman thinks the BPP should help young people start families because there are fewer births than deaths in their community.
A dispute arose among BPP trustees over allotting a charity flat to the son of a former police officer.
Three trustees opposed the allotment due to the applicant's residency and income concerns, while three supported it.
The chairman's casting vote approved the allotment, but dissenting trustees issued a public statement.
The BPP issued a public notice seeking community input on the allotment decision.
The chairman argued for leniency to support young families in a declining community.
- Who
- Trustees of the Bombay Parsi Punchayet (BPP) and the son of a former police officer
- What
- A dispute over the allotment of a charity flat in a Parsi community housing estate
- Where
- Mumbai, India, specifically in the Godrej Baug colony on Nepean Sea Road
- When
- Recently, with ongoing debates and public notices
- Why
- Disagreement over the applicant's eligibility based on income and residency status, and differing views on community priorities
Key facts
- Organization
- Bombay Parsi Punchayet (BPP)
- Location
- Mumbai, India
- Applicant
- Son of a former police officer
- Voting Result
- 3-3 tie, chairman's vote decided
- Community Population
- 300 births vs. 900 deaths annually
- Eligibility Issue
- Applicant's income and residency status
- Trustee Protest
- Dissenting trustees issued public statement
- Public Notice
- BPP seeks community input on allotment
Quotes
Viraf Mehta
Chairman of the Bombay Parsi Punchayet
“In our dying community, there are not many people who marry early and plan a family. We have 300 annual births compared to 900 deaths. What is the harm in showing some leniency to a young man who wants to start a family?”
freepressjournal.in
“Besides, the family has served not just the community, but the city and country. The son was sent abroad to study because his father's job as a public investigator put him at risk.”
freepressjournal.in
Adil Malia
Dissenting trustee of the Bombay Parsi Punchayet
“However, the trust is yet to allot the flat. The public notice has been issued to inform community members that if there are people who have better claims on the flats, they can apply.”
freepressjournal.in
“A majority vote, like in this case, should be final but not an ad hoc process. Public notice is a learned process.”
freepressjournal.in
