Archive · 12 Sep 2026
Suvendu Adhikari’s Chinmoy Krishna Remarks Spark Bengal Identity Clash
Suvendu Adhikari said Bengali Hindus need a homeland and connected this idea to the case of Bangladeshi monk Chinmoy Krishna Das.
He said Bengal’s connection with India protected Bengali Hindus during Partition.
He also remembered that his mother’s family had to leave what is now Bangladesh because they were Hindu.
The CPI(M) criticized him and the BJP for using different standards in Bangladesh and India.
It pointed to Umar Khalid, who is also in jail in India.
Adhikari blamed earlier Left and TMC governments for moving Bengal away from Hindu traditions.
He said this year’s Durga Puja would follow traditional rules.
CPI(M) leaders said politicians should not decide what people read or how they celebrate festivals.
The disagreement has become part of a larger fight about religion, history and minority rights in Bengal.
Suvendu Adhikari invoked jailed Bangladeshi monk Chinmoy Krishna Das while arguing that Bengal should remain a homeland for Bengali Hindus.
Adhikari credited Syama Prasad Mookerjee and Swami Pranavananda with helping secure Bengal’s accession to India and recalled his mother’s Partition-era displacement.
CPI(M) leader Kaltan Dasgupta accused the BJP of double standards by comparing Chinmoy Krishna’s detention in Bangladesh with Umar Khalid’s detention in India.
Adhikari accused past Left Front and TMC governments of weakening Bengal’s religious traditions and said this year’s Durga Puja would follow the traditional almanac.
CPI(M) leaders rejected Adhikari’s prescriptions over festival observances and literature stalls, framing the dispute as a conflict over secularism, civil liberties and majoritarian politics.
- Who
- BJP leader Suvendu Adhikari, CPI(M) leaders Kaltan Dasgupta and Sujan Chakraborty, and figures including Chinmoy Krishna Das and Umar Khalid.
- What
- A political dispute over Bengali Hindu identity, Partition, minority rights, detention and the role of religious traditions in Bengal.
- When
- Adhikari made the remarks at a Ganesh Puja inauguration on Saturday; the debate also concerns this year’s Durga Puja.
- Where
- Rajarhat Gopalpur and the wider political debate in Bengal, with references to Bangladesh and India.
- Why
- Adhikari sought to highlight Bengali Hindu security and the legacy of Bengal’s accession to India, while the CPI(M) challenged the BJP’s record on minority rights and civil liberties.
CPI(M) and secularism
BJP and Bengali Hindu identity
Minority rights and detention
CPI(M) and secularism
The CPI(M) says it supports minority rights across Bangladesh, India and Palestine, and argues that the BJP applies double standards by highlighting Chinmoy Krishna’s detention while Umar Khalid remains jailed in India.
BJP and Bengali Hindu identity
Adhikari uses Chinmoy Krishna’s case and the treatment of Hindus in Bangladesh to argue that Bengali Hindus need the protection of their own homeland.
Religion and cultural traditions
CPI(M) and secularism
CPI(M) leaders say the chief minister should not dictate what people read, eat or call their festivals, and that celebrations and party literature stalls will continue as before.
BJP and Bengali Hindu identity
Adhikari accuses the Left and TMC of suppressing Bengal’s religious and cultural traditions and says festivals should follow traditional rituals and the almanac.
History and political identity
CPI(M) and secularism
The CPI(M) frames the BJP’s campaign as majoritarian politics and seeks to broaden the debate toward secularism, civil liberties and dissent within India.
BJP and Bengali Hindu identity
The BJP seeks to center Bengal’s political narrative on Partition, Bengali Hindu identity and the legacy of Syama Prasad Mookerjee and Swami Pranavananda.
- Central reference
- Chinmoy Krishna Das has been in Bangladeshi custody since November 2024 in a case linked to alleged offences against the state.
- Parole
- Das was recently allowed five hours to attend his mother’s last rites, according to the article.
- Adhikari’s historical argument
- He credited Syama Prasad Mookerjee and Swami Pranavananda with the struggle to secure a homeland for Bengali Hindus.
- Partition reference
- Adhikari said his mother, Gayatri Devi, fled to India with her father because they were Hindus.
- Indian detention comparison
- CPI(M) leader Kaltan Dasgupta cited Umar Khalid’s detention while accusing the BJP of double standards.
- Festival policy
- Adhikari said this year’s Durga Puja would follow the traditional almanac and that liquor shops would be closed on Ashtami.
- Cultural dispute
- The disagreement includes whether festival celebrations should use the term “Durga Puja” or “Sharadotsav,” as well as the presence of Marxist literature stalls.