Archive · 2 Nov 2025
Columnist Critiques Grand Displays of Patriotism in India
A writer named Tavleen Singh watched a lot of TV one morning.
She saw that all the news channels were showing a big celebration for a leader named Sardar Patel.
There were dancers and songs, and the Prime Minister seemed to enjoy it.
But, she noticed that other important news, like a meeting between two world leaders, was not being shown.
Tavleen thought these big shows of patriotism are like something from less confident countries.
She believes that if India is truly a strong democracy, it doesn't need to put on such parades.
She also mentioned that many young people are trying to leave India to find better lives, even facing hardship, which makes her question the idea of a 'new India'.
Instead of big shows, she thinks people should focus on cleaning up their country.
Columnist Tavleen Singh expresses concern over excessive public displays of patriotism and nationalism in India.
She criticizes the overwhelming live coverage of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel's anniversary celebration, overshadowing other significant global news.
Singh argues that a confident democracy like India does not need grand spectacles to demonstrate its patriotism or national unity.
She contrasts current practices with a past era where patriotism was deeply felt but not overtly performed.
The author suggests focusing on practical initiatives like Swachh Bharat 2.0 over 'dodgy nationalism' and grand shows.
- Who
- Columnist Tavleen Singh
- What
- Critique of public displays of patriotism and nationalism, particularly those organized by the government.
- When
- During the celebration of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel's 150th birth anniversary.
- Where
- India, with specific reference to news coverage and the Statue of Unity.
- Why
- The author believes such spectacles are unnecessary for a confident democracy and detract from genuine issues, comparing them unfavorably to past practices and international norms.
- Author
- Tavleen Singh
- Date of Writing
- As the day the column is written
- Event Critiqued
- Celebration of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel's 150th birth anniversary at the Statue of Unity
- Alternative News Ignored
- Meeting between Donald Trump and Xi Jinping
- Author's Suggestion
- Focus on Swachh Bharat 2.0 instead of patriotic spectacles