Archive · 23 Jul 2025
India's Tax Burden Debate: Reddit User's Job Offer Dilemma
Imagine someone is offered a much better job, but the government takes a big chunk of the extra money in taxes.
This person, who already earns a good salary, is worried because almost half of the extra money they earn will go to taxes.
They feel it's not worth working harder if most of the extra money goes to the government without getting more benefits.
Many other people online agree, feeling that the tax system in India isn't fair to those with high salaries.
They suggest asking for different types of pay or even not taking the job if it doesn't make them much richer after taxes.
A Reddit user sparked debate by questioning a ₹75 lakh job offer due to increased taxes.
The user currently earns ₹48 lakh and pays around ₹12 lakh in income taxes.
The new offer would almost double the tax liability to ₹22 lakh due to the 10% surcharge.
The post highlighted middle-class frustration with India's tax structure for salaried individuals.
Commenters suggested alternatives like negotiating pay structures or rejecting the offer.
- Who
- A Reddit user and other Indian professionals.
- What
- A Reddit user's concerns over high income tax rates with a new job offer sparked a debate on India's tax structure.
- When
- The debate occurred after the user posted about a job offer.
- Where
- Online, on Reddit, and pertaining to income tax in India.
- Why
- Because the user was concerned about a large increase in taxes without corresponding benefits.
High Taxpayers
N/A
Incentives
High Taxpayers
Feel disincentivized to earn more due to high tax rates with limited public service improvements.
N/A
N/A
Tax vs. Value
High Taxpayers
Believe the government's share grows disproportionately, making career advancement seem less valuable.
N/A
N/A
- Current Salary
- ₹48 lakh annually
- Current Tax Paid
- ₹12 lakh
- New Job Offer
- ₹75 lakh annually
- Estimated Tax on New Offer
- ₹22 lakh
- Surcharge Trigger
- 10% surcharge on income exceeding ₹50 lakh