Archive · 27 Oct 2025
Supreme Court Rejects Plea for Vehicle Star-Rating System
A person asked the Supreme Court to make a rule about how cars get rated for how much pollution they cause.
This is similar to how appliances get energy efficiency ratings.
The goal was to help people buy cars that create less pollution, making the air cleaner and healthier.
The Court said no, explaining that it's a decision for the government to make, not the courts.
They suggested the person ask the government directly.
The person argued that such systems already exist in other countries and that air pollution is a serious health problem in India, causing many deaths and birth defects.
The Court acknowledged his concern but declined to interfere.
The Supreme Court declined a plea for a nationwide vehicle star-rating system.
The petitioner sought a system to promote less polluting vehicles.
The court cited that this matter falls under the state's domain.
The petitioner highlighted the health hazards from vehicular pollution.
The Bharat New Car Assessment Programme (BNCAP) remains a draft.
- Who
- Sanjay Kulshresthra, the Supreme Court
- What
- Supreme Court refused to implement a vehicle star-rating system
- When
- Monday
- Where
- Supreme Court
- Why
- The court decided the matter falls within the domain of the State
- Case Outcome
- Supreme Court declined to intervene
- Petitioner
- Sanjay Kulshresthra
- Plea Purpose
- Implement nationwide vehicle star-rating
- Court's Reasoning
- Issue is a matter for the Executive branch
- Existing System
- Bharat New Car Assessment Programme (BNCAP)
- BNCAP Status
- Pending as draft since July 2023
- Petitioner's Argument
- Star-rating helps buyers choose less polluting vehicles