4 hrs ago
Saharanpur mosque demolition row intensifies after ancient well discovery
A well was found under the remains of a mosque in Saharanpur.
Experts from the Archaeological Survey of India visited the site to study it.
They said its bricks and building materials may be 200 to 250 years old.
The experts have not yet determined exactly when or why it was built.
Some people are speculating that it could be connected to an older religious site.
The ASI said there is not enough evidence to make that conclusion yet.
Government ministers said the mosque was demolished through a legal process.
The discovery has led to a new political argument while the matter is also before the court.
An Archaeological Survey of India team examined a nearly 20-foot-deep well found beneath debris at the demolished mosque site.
ASI officials said the well uses Lakhauri bricks and lime-surki, suggesting it may date from 200 to 250 years ago.
The ASI cautioned that debris prevented a definitive assessment of the structure’s age, purpose or history.
Ministers Brijesh Pathak, Narendra Kashyap and O.P. Rajbhar said the demolition followed legal or court procedures.
Speculation about links to the Shahjahan period or a former temple remains unverified, while the issue has triggered fresh political debate.
- Who
- The Archaeological Survey of India team, including Assistant Archaeological Officer Manoj Kumar Yadav, examined the well; Uttar Pradesh ministers also commented on the controversy.
- What
- A nearly 20-foot-deep, possibly 200-to-250-year-old well was discovered beneath debris at the site of a demolished mosque.
- Where
- Inside the Saharanpur Collectorate premises in Saharanpur, Uttar Pradesh.
- When
- The well was discovered on Sunday, and the ASI inspected it on Monday; the political controversy was reported on Tuesday.
- Why
- The inspection was conducted to determine the well’s age, nature and possible historical significance, prompting debate over the mosque’s demolition and the site’s history.
Calls for caution and legal scrutiny
Government defense of demolition
Historical interpretation
Calls for caution and legal scrutiny
The ASI said the well’s exact history has not been established and warned against conclusions linking it to the Shahjahan period, a temple or another religious site without further evidence.
Government defense of demolition
Minister Narendra Kashyap said the discovery should be considered in assessing the circumstances of the site and argued that the well provided additional context for the dispute.
Legality of the demolition
Calls for caution and legal scrutiny
The discovery has fueled renewed political questioning of the demolition, including criticism associated in the report with Samajwadi Party leader Akhilesh Yadav.
Government defense of demolition
Narendra Kashyap said the mosque was demolished through due legal procedure, while O.P. Rajbhar said it was demolished following a court order.
Public and political response
Calls for caution and legal scrutiny
The ongoing inspection and unresolved historical questions have kept the controversy open.
Government defense of demolition
Deputy Chief Minister Brijesh Pathak declined to comment substantively because the matter is before the court and emphasized maintaining law and order.
Key facts
- Estimated age
- Approximately 200 to 250 years, according to a preliminary assessment based on construction materials and techniques.
- Depth
- Nearly 20 feet.
- Materials
- Lakhauri bricks and lime-surki.
- Inspection agency
- Archaeological Survey of India.
- ASI officer
- Manoj Kumar Yadav, Assistant Archaeological Officer.
- Site
- Saharanpur Collectorate premises, where the mosque had stood.
- Historical assessment
- A definitive conclusion is pending because debris remains inside the structure.
Quotes
Narendra Kashyap
Uttar Pradesh minister
“We will maintain law and order in Uttar Pradesh. Since the matter is before the court, it would not be appropriate to comment on it. The courts always keep options open. We are committed to maintaining law and order in Uttar Pradesh.”
thehansindia.com
“Akhilesh Yadav should also look at the situation after the mosque was demolished. A well was found at the site where the mosque had been built. Wells have historically been one of the oldest ways of providing water to people.”
thehansindia.com
Sources
Related news
Well Found Beneath Demolished Mosque Debris in Saharanpur, ASI Informed
ASI To Examine Well Found After Saharanpur Mosque Demolition
Century-Old Well Discovered Beneath Demolished Saharanpur Mosque Site
Saharanpur Mosque Demolition Sparks Political Row Over Court Action
Saharanpur Mosque Demolished After Court Upholds Government Land Claim
Saharanpur Mosque Demolished After Court Ruling, Triggering Political Clash
CRPF Deputy Commandant Wins ₹50 Lakh on KBC 18
