Archive · 23 Jul 2025
Viceroy Alleges Vedanta's Hindustan Zinc of Siphoning Profits and Mismanagement
Imagine a company (HZL) that mines zinc.
A research firm (Viceroy) says that the owners of HZL are making extra money unfairly.
They claim the owners have another company (MRPL) that sells things to HZL at high prices.
Viceroy also says HZL paid out too much money to its investors, possibly borrowing money to do so.
HZL says this is not true, and that it follows all the rules and is doing well, making money for shareholders and the government.
The research firm says the owners are unfairly benefiting, and HZL is taking on debt.
HZL says the brand fee it pays is justified and follows industry standards.
Viceroy Research alleges Vedanta Group promoters are siphoning profits from Hindustan Zinc Ltd (HZL) through an exclusive supply deal.
Viceroy claims a 49% promoter-owned entity, Minova Runaya Pvt. Ltd (MRPL), sells mining products to HZL at a 30% markup.
HZL has denied the allegations, stating they follow stringent governance protocols.
Viceroy also alleges HZL paid out more in dividends than it earned, potentially using debt to cover the shortfall.
HZL refutes these claims, highlighting its growth and contribution to stakeholder value.
- Who
- Viceroy Research, Vedanta Group, Hindustan Zinc Ltd (HZL), and Minova Runaya Pvt. Ltd (MRPL).
- What
- Allegations of profit siphoning and financial mismanagement against Hindustan Zinc Ltd by Viceroy Research.
- When
- Recent reports and financial periods between FY21 and FY26 are referenced.
- Where
- Focus is on activities related to Hindustan Zinc Ltd (HZL) in India.
- Why
- Viceroy Research alleges improper financial practices, including inflated supply deals and unsustainable dividend payouts potentially to benefit the promoters.
Viceroy Research
Hindustan Zinc Ltd (HZL)
Alleged Profit Siphoning
Viceroy Research
Vedanta Group promoters are siphoning profits via an exclusive supply deal.
Hindustan Zinc Ltd (HZL)
HZL denies any wrongdoing, asserting its commitment to governance and due diligence processes.
Dividend and Free Cash Flow
Viceroy Research
HZL has not generated Rs 10,000 crore in FCF since 2023 and paid out too many dividends. The brand fee is an uncommercial contract.
Hindustan Zinc Ltd (HZL)
HZL states that they operate within a stringent governance framework and have created immense shareholder value.
- HZL Share Price (at closing on Wednesday)
- ₹446.9 apiece
- Vedanta Ltd Share Price (at closing on Wednesday)
- ₹455.6 apiece
- MRPL Ownership (Vedanta)
- 49%
- MRPL Revenue (FY21-FY24)
- ₹553 crore
- MRPL Profit (FY21-FY24)
- ₹92 crore
- HZL Dividend (FY23)
- ₹31,000 crore
- HZL FCF shortfall estimate (first quarter ended June 2025)
- ₹3,600 crore