Archive · 2 Jul 2025
X Corp Challenges India's Content Takedown Orders
X, a social media company, is in a legal fight with the Indian government over requests to remove content.
X believes the government is overstepping its bounds and using the requests to censor information.
The government says it needs to issue these requests to make sure social media companies follow the law.
X argues the government's process violates the constitution, while the government insists its actions are lawful and necessary.
X Corp is challenging content takedown orders from the Indian government.
X argues the government is using takedown notices to bypass Section 69A of the IT Act.
The company claims the Sahyog portal functions as a censorship portal.
The government denies Meity directs ministries to issue the notices.
The Centre defends Rule 3(1)(d), stating it has safeguards and does not equate to information blocking.
- Who
- X Corp and the Indian government.
- What
- Legal dispute over content takedown notices.
- When
- Recently, during a hearing.
- Where
- Karnataka High Court in India.
- Why
- X Corp is challenging the government's authority to issue takedown notices.
X Corp's Stance
Indian Government's Stance
Portal Functionality
X Corp's Stance
The Sahyog portal, which is termed as a "censorship portal," is illegal.
Indian Government's Stance
The Centre denies that the ministries are issuing notifications at the behest of Meity.
Takedown Processes
X Corp's Stance
X argues that the takedown notices are designed to bypass Section 69A of the IT Act and circumvent established processes.
Indian Government's Stance
The Centre defends Rule 3(1)(d), stating it has safeguards to prevent misuse.
- Plaintiff
- X Corp
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- Key Issue
- Content takedown orders
- Relevant Act
- Section 69A of the Information Technology Act
- Government Portal
- Sahyog portal
Sources
X lawyer’s “Tom, Dick and Harry” remark in HC for government officials sparks a row
Musk’s X faces heat in India over ‘Tom, Dick and Harry’ jibe at govt officials during court hearing
X, India Spar Over Lawyer's 'Tom, Dick, And Harry' Remark For Government Officials
'Tom, Dick and Harry' remark brings trouble for Elon Musk's X in India: Here's what happened