2 weeks ago
Rejected Songs That Became Hits: Madonna, Rihanna and More
Sometimes a singer says no to a song, and another singer turns it into a huge hit.
This article tells the stories of famous songs that were rejected before they became classics.
The Beatles wrote Misery for a young singer named Helen Shapiro, but her record label passed on it.
Holiday was played for Mary Wilson before Madonna made it her first international top 10 hit.
...Baby One More Time was turned down by TLC and Robyn before Britney Spears recorded it.
Umbrella was offered to Britney Spears and then Mary J. Blige, but Rihanna insisted the song was hers, and it topped charts worldwide.
The Beach Boys kept Don't Worry Baby after producer Phil Spector rejected it, and it became one of their most loved songs.
Kylie Minogue's Can't Get You Out of My Head was first offered to S Club 7, whose manager passed on it.
Golden Years was written for Elvis Presley, but he passed, and David Bowie recorded it instead.
So a song one artist turns down can still become a world-famous favourite for someone else.
Holiday was first offered to Mary Wilson of The Supremes before Madonna turned it into her first international top 10 hit.
...Baby One More Time was rejected by TLC and Robyn before Britney Spears recorded it and became a global star.
Umbrella, passed over by Britney Spears' camp and Mary J. Blige, was claimed by Rihanna, featuring Jay-Z, and topped charts worldwide.
Shape of You began as a song imagined for Rihanna before Ed Sheeran kept it, making it one of the most streamed records ever released.
Elvis Presley declined Golden Years (later a David Bowie hit), Steppenwolf took Born to Be Wild, and The Beatles' Misery was written for Helen Shapiro.
- Who
- Artists such as Madonna, Rihanna, Britney Spears, Beyoncé, Lady Gaga, Ed Sheeran, Bob Dylan, David Bowie and The Beatles, along with the singers and groups who rejected their songs first.
- What
- Hit songs that were turned down by other artists before being recorded by the acts that made them famous.
- Where
- Mostly the US and UK music industries, where the songs were written, rejected and recorded.
- When
- Stories spanning 1963 (The Beatles' Misery) to 2017 (Ed Sheeran's Shape of You).
- Why
- To highlight how songs that one artist passes on often become classics when another artist records them.
Key facts
- Article focus
- Classic songs rejected by one artist and later recorded as hits by another
- Song span
- 1963 (The Beatles' Misery) to 2017 (Ed Sheeran's Shape of You)
- Holiday
- Played first for Mary Wilson of The Supremes; became Madonna's first international top 10 hit
- ...Baby One More Time
- Rejected by TLC and Robyn; became Britney Spears' breakthrough single
- Umbrella
- Offered to Britney Spears and Mary J. Blige; recorded by Rihanna featuring Jay-Z, topping charts worldwide
- Golden Years
- Written for Elvis Presley; recorded by David Bowie in 1975
- Telephone
- Written for Britney Spears; recorded by Lady Gaga featuring Beyoncé
- How Will I Know
- Written for Janet Jackson; became a number one hit for Whitney Houston







