Archive · 12 Dec 2025
Heated Debate in Parliament Over Electoral Reforms
There was a big discussion in the Indian Parliament about the song Vande Mataram, which is 150 years old.
The Prime Minister, Narendra Modi, said that Jawaharlal Nehru and the Congress party had removed some parts of the song to please a minority group.
The Opposition said that the Prime Minister was not telling the whole truth.
A famous poet, Rabindranath Tagore, had suggested keeping only the first two parts of the song to avoid causing trouble.
Both the Congress and the group that wrote India's constitution agreed with this idea.
The shortened version of the song was accepted as the national song three years after India became independent.
Now, some people are using the song's history to cause division, which is sad because the song once united people during the fight for independence.
The principles of including everyone, despite their religion, were important during India's struggle for freedom and after.
However, this principle failed during the Partition, which divided India based on religion.
Additionally, there was a heated debate in Parliament over electoral reforms.
The Home Minister, Amit Shah, and the Leader of Opposition, Rahul Gandhi, had a strong argument.
The Opposition accused Shah of avoiding important questions and staged a walkout.
BJP leaders defended Shah, saying the Opposition was spreading false information.
Rahul Gandhi claimed Shah was under pressure and avoided addressing key issues.
The Parliament's Winter Session is ongoing and will continue until December 19.
PM Modi accused Nehru and Congress of minority appeasement in excising stanzas from Vande Mataram.
Opposition claimed PM Modi was misrepresenting historical facts about the song.
Tagore advised adopting the first two stanzas to avoid polarizing sentiments.
Both Congress and the Constituent Assembly agreed to abridge Vande Mataram based on Tagore's advice.
The abridged version of Vande Mataram was accepted as the national song three years post-Independence.
- Who
- PM Narendra Modi, Congress, Opposition, Rabindranath Tagore, Syama Prasad Mookerjee, Amit Shah, Rahul Gandhi, BJP leaders, Opposition MPs
- What
- Debate on the 150th anniversary of Vande Mataram and electoral reforms
- When
- December 1 to December 19 (Winter Session)
- Where
- Indian Parliament (Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha)
- Why
- To discuss the history and significance of Vande Mataram and electoral reforms.
- Primary Accusation
- PM Modi accused Nehru and Congress of minority appeasement in excising stanzas from Vande Mataram.
- Opposition's Response
- Opposition claimed PM Modi was misrepresenting historical facts.
- Historical Context
- Tagore advised adopting first two stanzas to avoid polarizing sentiments.
- Congress and Constituent Assembly
- Both agreed to abridge Vande Mataram based on Tagore's advice.
- National Song Adoption
- Abridged version of Vande Mataram accepted as national song three years post-Independence.
- Current Controversy
- Song's history being used as a tool for political division.
- Pluralism Principle
- India's freedom movement and republic's vision based on pluralism.
- Partition Context
- Religious inclusivity was fundamental but failed during Partition.
- Heated Exchange
- Rahul Gandhi and Amit Shah engaged in a verbal showdown over electoral reforms.
- Opposition Walkout
- Opposition staged a walkout during Shah's speech, accusing him of evasion.
- BJP's Defense
- BJP leaders praised Shah's speech, accusing Opposition of spreading misinformation.
- Rahul Gandhi's Allegations
- Gandhi claimed Shah was under pressure and avoided addressing key issues.
- Parliament Winter Session
- Session commenced on December 1 and scheduled to continue until December 19.
Sources
Vande Mataram debate | Aim is to malign Nehru: Congress; BJP flags ‘demographic invasion’
Rabindranath Tagore’s ‘Bande Mataram’ carried a message that ‘Vande Mataram’ did not
Shrill tone: Editorial on Parliament debate over ‘Vande Mataram’ on its 150th anniversary
Jairam Ramesh gives Maniben Patel's book to Rajnath amid Nehru-Babri row
Jairam gives Rajnath diary entries to rebut 'Nehru-Babri' claim
Jairam Ramesh gives Rajnath Singh Maniben Patel's diary to show Nehru never sought public funds for Babri
Parliament Winter Session Live Updates: Proceedings Begin In Lok Sabha And Rajya Sabha
BJP And Congress Trade Barbs After Heated Amit Shah–Rahul Gandhi Clash In Lok Sabha
His hands were shaking: Rahul on LS face-off with Shah
Lok Sabha extends term of panel studying ‘One Nation, One Election’ Bills
'His hands were shaking': Rahul on heated exchange with Shah
RS witnesses uproar as JP Nadda digs out Nehru's letters on Vande Mataram
BMC polls: How Vande Mataram helped Shiv Sena win power in Mumbai against odds
Patriotic tribute or ideological battleground? Fierce political storm in RS over Vande Mataram
Vande Mataram Should Be Accorded Same Status As National Anthem: JP Nadda
Vande Mataram should be accorded same status as national anthem: Nadda
Vande Mataram ‘one-day matter’ for BJP: Thackeray says party should not lecture him on Hindutva
Vande Mataram should be given same status as national anthem: Nadda
Congress targets EC over transparency concerns and seeks Parliamentary accountability
Parliament Winter Session: Vande Mataram and vote ‘chori’, all heat, little light
BJP targets Nehru on Vande Mataram decision as Rajya Sabha debate fuels fresh dispute