Archive · 21 Aug 2025
Government's Bill on Detained Ministers Sparks Controversy
The Indian government has proposed a new law that could remove leaders like the Prime Minister and ministers if they're in jail for more than a month.
The opposition worries this could be used unfairly.
The government says it wants to clean up politics.
The main question is why the government would propose a law it knows it probably can't pass in its current form.
Some people think it's to make the opposition look bad by blocking something that sounds like it's about stopping corruption.
The Indian government introduced a bill proposing removal of ministers, PMs, and CMs jailed for over 30 days.
The Opposition views the bill as a means for potential misuse, alleging a threat to democracy and federalism.
The government says the bill aims to elevate moral standards in politics.
The BJP lacks the necessary parliamentary numbers to pass the bill without opposition support.
Critics suggest the bill's introduction is a strategic move in a 'perception battle'.
- Who
- The Indian government (BJP) and the Opposition.
- What
- A bill proposing the removal of ministers, PMs, and CMs jailed for over 30 days.
- When
- Recently, during the ongoing parliamentary session.
- Where
- India.
- Why
- To influence public perception and put pressure on the opposition
Opposition
Government (Implied)
Democracy
Opposition
The bill is undemocratic.
Government (Implied)
N/A
Federalism
Opposition
The bill threatens federalism.
Government (Implied)
N/A
Misuse of Power
Opposition
The bill may be misused.
Government (Implied)
N/A
- Bill Name
- Constitution (130th Amendment) Bill
- Proposed By
- Indian Government
- Main Feature
- Removal of detained ministers
- Detention Threshold
- 30 days
- Government Stance
- Elevating moral standards
- Opposition Concern
- Potential for misuse
Sources
'Resign If Jailed...': What We Know On Bill To Remove PM, CMs, Likely To Be Tabled Today
Centre Likely To Table Bills That Can Sack PM, CMs & Top Ministers Held In Custody For 30 Days
Massive Political Row Over Modi Govt's Bill That Can Sack PM, CMs | WATCH Video
Govt to Introduce Bills to Remove Ministers Facing Serious Criminal Charges
Opposition Slams Govt Over New Bills in LS
Amit Shah introduces bill in Parliament to remove PM, CMs & ministers if arrested
No escape for 'tainted' leaders? Amit Shah to table bills that could sack PM, CMs, ministers facing criminal charges. Here's what it means
'Won’t let it pass': Clash over bill to remove arrested PMs, Chief Ministers
"Draconian law, diversionary tactic": KC Venugopal on J-K Constitution Amendment Bill
'Remember Arvind Kejriwal': Opposition Slams Centre Over 'PM Removal' Bill
Amit Shah to introduce bills on removal of PM, CMs, Ministers facing arrest; key provisions and objects
Amit Shah to introduce bills on removal of PM, CMs, Ministers facing arrest; key provisions and objects
Shashi Tharoor Differs With Congress Again On 'Bill To Remove PM, Chief Ministers'
Why the amendment bill to remove ministers detained on graft charges has great scope for misuse
Bills for sacking CMs, Ministers a ‘death knell’ for federalism, assault on Opp states: INDIA bloc
Anti-Constitutional: Priyanka Gandhi on bills proposing norms to remove PM, CM over criminal charges
AAP on Centre’s new Bills for jailed ministers: ‘This was always govt plan, to stop Oppn’
Amit Shah tables Bills seeking removal of PM, CMs facing serious criminal charges, to be referred to Joint panel
Bills to remove arrested PM, CMs, ministers tabled: Draft to be sent to JPC, says Amit Shah amid Oppn uproar in Parliament
Parliament Monsoon Session Day 20 LIVE: Amit Shah Tables Bill To Remove PM, CM On Serious Charges, J&K Reorganization; Opp Says Violates Article 21
Explained: Centre's 3 Bills on removal of PM, CMs and other ministers facing criminal charges
‘Seems reasonable…’: Shashi Tharoor differs with Congress on bills to remove PM, CMs who spend 30 days in jail
Chaos In House As Amit Shah Introduces Bill On Removal Of PM, Chief Ministers
What’s in the 3 New Bills Tabled By Home Minister Amit Shah In Lok Sabha
High drama in Lok Sabha as govt introduces bills to remove PM, CMs, ministers; Opposition MPs throw torn copies towards Amit Shah
Opposition Slams It, Tharoor Backs It: What The ‘Bill To Remove PM, CMs’ Really Proposes
Papers torn, MPs come close to scuffle as Lok Sabha sees pandemonium over Bill to remove ministers detained on graft charges
Congress vs Shashi Tharoor on bills to remove PM, CMs and ministers held in 30-day custody
Centre introduces bills for removal of PM, CMs and ministers held on serious criminal charges
‘Super emergency, Hitlerian assault on Indian democracy’: Mamata slams 130th Constitutional Amendment Bill
Amit Shah tables bill to remove PM, CMs, ministers amid chaos
'Seems Reasonable...': Congress' Shashi Tharoor Differs From Party On Bill Removing CM, Ministers Accused Of Serious Crimes
Opposition Hits New Low, Tears Bill Papers And Throws Towards HM Amit Shah | Watch
Mamata Banerjee Alleges 130th Constitutional Amendment Bill Threatens Democracy in India
5 reasons why opposition is against the bill that seeks to remove jailed PM, CMs and ministers
Amit Shah Silences Congress’ K.C. Venugopal in Lok Sabha Over 3 Key Bills
Bills to remove PM, CMs, ministers in 30-day custody referred to JPC after Opposition uproar
Constitution Amendment Bill sent to Joint Committee of Parliament after Amit Shah introduces it in the Lok Sabha
Bills for removal of PM, CMs, ministers arrested on criminal charges referred to Joint par panel
Parliament Monsoon Session LIVE: Lok Sabha adjourned till 5pm, ‘Criminal’ MP removal Bills referred to JPC amid uproar
Lok Sabha refers Bills on removal of jailed PM, CMs, ministers to Joint Committee
Tharoor Bucks Party Line Yet Again, Says Bill to Remove PM, CM With Criminal Charges 'Seems Reasonable'
‘They Attacked...’: TMC's Mitali Bagh Says Union Ministers Rijiju, Ravneet Bittu ‘Assaulted’ Her
Kiren Rijiju, Ravneet Bittu Assaulted Women MPs: Trinamool's Big Allegation
‘Reasonable’: Tharoor differs from Congress, again; backs bill to remove ‘PM, CMs and ministers’ – Watch
Anti-Graft Bills Showdown: Amit Shah, Piyush Goyal & Pralhad Joshi In Crucial Meet With Om Birla
Opposition MPs tear copies of three bills, throw papers bits at Amit Shah as he speaks
Clean Politics or Toppling Tool?: Bill That Allows Centre to Sack Arrested CMs
Constitution (130th amendment) Bill, 2025 sent to Join Committee amid uproar: 5 things you need to know
Amit Shah Gives PM Modi Example To Defend ‘Tainted' Leader Bill, Invokes Indira To Slam Congress
From Kejriwal To Lalu Prasad, Here Are CMs & Ministers Who Refused To Resign Despite Arrest
Bills on removal of jailed PMs, CMs, Ministers will enable ‘vendetta politics’: CPI
Shashi Tharoor says media twisted remarks on bill to remove PM, CMs jailed for 30 days
Gestapo In The Making? Here's What 130th Constitution Amendment Bill Actually Proposes
M A Baby writes: Bill to remove arrested ministers is an attack on Opposition, not corruption
PM Modi bringing himself into the ambit of law, Congress did reverse in Indira rule: Amit Shah
Modi’s Crackdown On ‘Tainted’: Ouster Clause Sparks Oppn Fury, Papers Thrown At Shah | Blueprint
‘Draconian’: Opposition on bills for removal of PM, CMs and ministers held on criminal charges
Black Day, Black Bill: Stalin on 130th Constitutional Amendment Bill
'Modi govt taking India back to medieval times': Rahul Gandhi on bills aiming to remove PM, other leaders facing serious charges
Rush Hour: Bills on removal of arrested ministers spark row, Israel approves Gaza City plan, & more
'Back To Medieval Times': Rahul Gandhi On Bill To Sack Arrested Ministers
Lok Sabha passes constitutional amendment bill as Amit Shah says jailed leaders cannot “run governments from jail”
Shashi Tharoor differs with Congress again; backs bills to remove PM, CMs as ‘reasonable’
"Governments Can't Be Run From Jail": Amit Shah On 'Criminal Ministers' Bill
NC Urges Centre to Relook 'Draconian' Provisions in Three Bills
MPs come close to scuffle, papers torn as govt introduces Bills to remove ministers detained on graft charges
130th Constitutional Amendment Bill assault on federalism: CPI(ML)
Congress Leader's 'Morality' Question To Amit Shah, His 'I Resigned' Reply
‘Misquoted by media’: Shashi Tharoor on disqualification bills
Tamil Nadu CM MK Stalin Terms 130th Amendment Bill A ‘Sinister Move To Intimidate Regional Parties’
Shah tables bills for removal of PM, CMs, ministers held for 30 days amid fierce opposition protest
Step by Centre towards something “more than a super- emergency”, says Mamata Banerjee condemning the 130th Constitutional Amendment Bill
'Modi govt taking India back to medieval times': Rahul Gandhi on bills aiming to remove PM, other leaders facing serious charges
‘A constable now can have power to change govts, and always of Opposition’: Abhishek Singhvi
‘Going back to medieval times’: Rahul Gandhi slams govt over PM, CMs removal bills
Kerala slams Bill to remove CM/PM; says ploy to hunt down non-BJP govts
Cong opposition to 3 bills testify their legacy to protect tainted leaders, says Amit Shah
What happened in Parliament would bring shame to any civilised society: BJP on Trinamool MPs tearing, throwing Bills at HM
'Undermines democracy': Stalin criticises Centre over 130th Constitution Amendment bill
'BJP rewriting Constitution': Abhishek Banerjee slams new bills to remove PM, CMs on criminal charge
Rahul Gandhi's Jibe on PM, CM Removal Bills: 'Face Not Liked? ED Case, You're Gone'
Country would have to decide if criminals could run governments: Amit Shah
'Naidu, Nitish Need To Be Threatened': Opposition's Take On Need For 'Tainted PM-CM' Bill
Jail Term To Cost Power? PM, CMs & Mins Included In Bill, Oppn Decries 'Super Emergency' | Newshour
'Law Breakers Can't Be Law Makers': SC's Amicus Curiae Backs Anti-Graft Bill As 'Welcome Step'
India’s Biggest Reform Sparks Row: Modi Targets ‘Chori’, Congress Leads Blockade | India Upfront
Owaisi Slams Centre Over PM, CMs Removal Bill
‘Dictatorship bid’ cry from Opposition as govt unveils bills to remove arrested ministers
Attempt to Silence BJP Critics: KTR
Oppn protests Bills on removal of arrested PM, CMs and ministers
NDA allies back govt on Bills to sack arrested ministers
Removal Of PM, CMs Jailed On Serious Charges: Chaos in LS as Shah tables 3 Bills
Governments can't be run from jail: HM
Assault on democracy: Left parties
Opposition tears ‘draconian bills to disrupt states’ in Amit Shah’s face - Telegraph India
Caution on one-party rule, lawyers voice concern over misuse of Constitution Bill - Telegraph India
Shortcut by law
Centre’s proposed amendment to remove ministers from office: What SC has previously said on the matter
Mamata calls Shah’s Constitution Bill a ‘death knell for Indian democracy’ - Telegraph India
Parliament Session: Faceoff Between Oppn, Govt In LS After Amit Shah Tables 3 'Anti-Graft' Bills
Monsoon session of Parliament to conclude today
Amit Shah Tables 3 Anti-Graft Bills In Lok Sabha: Will The Bills Pass Parliament Test? | WATCH
‘Have you heard of anything more bizarre?' P Chidambaram slams bills for removal of PM, CMs, ministers
'Probity In Public Life': What's The Road Ahead For The Bills To Remove 'Tainted' PM, CMs, Ministers?
Letters to the editor: Cambridge Dictionary adds ‘skibidi’, ‘delulu’ and ‘tradwife’ to its pages
Express View: New Bills on ministers with criminal charges are bad faith, bad law
"Anything More Bizarre...": P Chidambaram On 'Sack Jailed Ministers' Bill
Tharoor differs with Cong on Bill removing PM, CMs
"To Blackmail, Torture Nitish Kumar": Tejashwi Yadav On Bill To Sack Ministers
Why BJP Brought Bill To Sack Jailed Ministers When It Does Not Have Numbers
‘PM, CMs Removal Bill Brought To Keep Nitish Kumar, Chandrababu Naidu In Check’: Tejashwi Yadav
12 of their sitting ministers held since 2014, most for more than 30 days: Why new Bills worry Oppn
Parliament Monsoon session: 12 bills passed in Lok Sabha, 14 in Rajya Sabha amid repeated disruptions
Why Narendra Modi Govt may find it tough to pass bills on PM, CM removal in Parliament: Explained in 5 points
Mayawati opposes 130th Constitution Amendment Bill
