Archive · 7 Sep 2026
Nike Leaves S&P 100 as Experts Debate Its Recovery
Nike has been part of a group of 100 very large companies called the S&P 100 for 18 years.
It will leave that group in September 2026, although it will remain in the larger S&P 500.
Experts disagree about why Nike has struggled.
Some say the company focused too much on online sales, data, and quick profits.
They believe this hurt its stores, retail partners, and connection with shoppers.
Others say Nike’s cultural and social messages pushed some customers away.
Another group says the main problem was weaker retail execution, not politics.
Nike’s new CEO, Elliott Hill, is changing some strategies, but competition in China remains a major challenge.
Nike will leave the S&P 100 before U.S. markets open on September 21, 2026, after 18 years in the index.
The company will remain in the broader S&P 500 despite its removal from the top-100 benchmark.
Critics blame Nike’s focus on digital sales, short-term efficiency, and data-driven marketing for weakening retail relationships and brand-building.
Some commentators attribute Nike’s problems to cultural messaging, while other analysts say poor retail execution is the primary issue.
New CEO Elliott Hill is reversing some sales strategies, but Nike faces strong competition, particularly in China.
- Who
- Nike, its new CEO Elliott Hill, and analysts and commentators discussing the company’s performance.
- What
- Nike is being removed from the S&P 100 while remaining in the S&P 500, prompting debate about its business problems and recovery prospects.
- When
- The change takes effect before U.S. markets open on September 21, 2026.
- Where
- The index change concerns U.S. markets; the article also highlights Nike’s running-shoe growth in North America and competition in China.
- Why
- S&P Dow Jones Indices announced the change as part of a quarterly rebalance, while experts cited Nike’s strategic choices, retail execution, cultural messaging, and competition as factors in its struggles.
Strategy and Culture Critics
Execution and Competition Analysts
Main cause of Nike’s struggles
Strategy and Culture Critics
Critics argue that Nike overemphasized digital sales, measurable marketing, short-term profits, and cultural messaging, weakening its brand and alienating some customers.
Execution and Competition Analysts
Other analysts argue that poor retail execution, weakened relationships with traditional retailers, and reduced understanding of customer demand are the central problems.
Meaning of the S&P 100 exit
Strategy and Culture Critics
Commentators such as Benny Johnson describe the removal after 18 years as evidence of a dramatic decline for a once highly influential consumer brand.
Execution and Competition Analysts
Other experts view the index change as a sign of current weakness but point to recent improvements under Elliott Hill and renewed growth in North American running shoes.
Path to recovery
Strategy and Culture Critics
The cultural-criticism view suggests Nike must reconnect with everyday shoppers and avoid messaging that alienates parts of its customer base.
Execution and Competition Analysts
The business-focused view emphasizes restoring retail strength, improving product and marketing decisions, and responding to competition, especially in China.
- Index change
- Nike will leave the S&P 100 but remain in the S&P 500.
- Effective date
- Before U.S. markets open on September 21, 2026.
- Time in index
- Nike has been in the S&P 100 for 18 years.
- Other departures
- Honeywell Aerospace, Simon Property Group, and Colgate-Palmolive are also leaving the S&P 100.
- New additions
- Dell Technologies, Palo Alto Networks, Arista Networks, and Sandisk are joining the index.
- Strategy criticism
- Experts criticized Nike’s emphasis on direct online sales, digital marketing, data, and short-term efficiency.
- Recovery effort
- CEO Elliott Hill is reversing some sales strategies, while Nike’s North American running-shoe business is showing growth.
- Major challenge
- Competition in China is identified as a significant obstacle to Nike’s recovery.