Archive · 30 Sep 2026
Naman Dhir’s Diving Catch Sparks Debate in India-West Indies ODI
Naman Dhir made a very difficult catch during the India-West Indies second ODI.
Keacy Carty hit the ball after edging a delivery from Prasidh Krishna.
The ball looked as if it might fall close to the ground.
Dhir quickly moved forward and caught it with both hands.
The on-field umpires were not immediately sure that the catch was fair.
They asked the third umpire to review it.
After checking another camera angle, the third umpire decided that Dhir’s fingers were under the ball.
This meant Carty was officially out.
People still discussed the catch because it looked very close to the ground.
Naman Dhir took a full-stretch catch at cover point to dismiss Keacy Carty.
Prasidh Krishna’s good-length delivery produced an outside edge from Carty.
The on-field umpires referred the dismissal to the third umpire after expressing uncertainty.
The third umpire reviewed another angle and ruled that Dhir’s fingers were underneath the ball.
The decision confirmed the catch as clean, although its closeness to the ground sparked debate.
- Who
- Naman Dhir caught Keacy Carty off Prasidh Krishna’s bowling during the India-West Indies second ODI.
- What
- A disputed diving catch was reviewed and ruled clean by the third umpire.
- When
- Wednesday; the article does not provide a calendar date.
- Where
- At the cover-point fielding position; the match venue is not specified.
- Why
- The on-field umpires were unsure whether Dhir had taken the ball cleanly with his fingers underneath it.
Catch Was Clean
Catch Deserved Scrutiny
Third-umpire decision
Catch Was Clean
The third umpire confirmed that Dhir’s fingers remained underneath the ball, so the dismissal was officially valid.
Catch Deserved Scrutiny
The on-field umpires were initially unsure, and the catch appeared close enough to the ground to prompt questions about whether it was taken fairly.
Interpretation of the effort
Catch Was Clean
Dhir completed a two-handed, full-stretch catch with his fingers underneath the ball.
Catch Deserved Scrutiny
The ball appeared to be dying in front of Dhir, making the exact moment of control difficult to judge without review.
- Match
- India vs West Indies, second ODI
- Dismissed batter
- Keacy Carty
- Bowler
- Prasidh Krishna
- Fielder
- Naman Dhir
- Decision
- Catch ruled clean by the third umpire
- Review basis
- An additional camera angle showed Dhir’s fingers underneath the ball