Archive · 31 Oct 2025
Fans Divided Over Liam Hemsworth Replacing Henry Cavill as Geralt in The Witcher Season 4
Imagine your favorite superhero suddenly had a different actor play them in a new movie.
That's what happened in The Witcher show on Netflix.
Henry Cavill, who played the monster hunter Geralt for three seasons, left the show.
Now, Liam Hemsworth is playing Geralt.
Many fans are sad and don't like the change, saying it doesn't feel the same and that Liam isn't as good as Henry.
They miss Henry's portrayal and feel the new season is missing something.
However, some fans are still enjoying the show, liking the story and the new characters joining, even if they are unsure about the new Geralt.
The show is continuing with Liam as Geralt for at least two more seasons.
Liam Hemsworth has taken over the role of Geralt in Netflix's 'The Witcher' Season 4, replacing Henry Cavill.
Many fans have voiced disappointment and criticism regarding Hemsworth's portrayal of the character.
Common complaints include a perceived lack of authenticity, conviction, and chemistry from Hemsworth's Geralt.
Despite negative reactions, some viewers have expressed positive sentiments about the season's plot and newly introduced characters.
New cast members joining Season 4 include Laurence Fishburne, Sharlto Copley, James Purefoy, and Danny Woodburn.
- Who
- Fans of Netflix's The Witcher, Liam Hemsworth, Henry Cavill
- What
- Disappointment and mixed reactions from fans following Liam Hemsworth's debut as Geralt in Season 4, replacing Henry Cavill.
- When
- Following the Season 4 premiere on Thursday
- Where
- Netflix
- Why
- Fans expressed dissatisfaction with the recasting, citing a perceived lack of authenticity and chemistry from the new lead, though some also praised plot developments and new characters.
Negative Fan Reactions
Positive/Mixed Fan Reactions
Geralt's Portrayal
Negative Fan Reactions
Fans feel Liam Hemsworth's Geralt is 'fake,' 'unconvincing,' lacks 'spark,' 'soul,' and chemistry with other characters, and doesn't match Henry Cavill's action hero status.
Positive/Mixed Fan Reactions
While some fans express mixed feelings, praising the action and familiar characters, others have found the new season's plot developments and favorite scenes coming to life positively.
Impact of Recasting
Negative Fan Reactions
The recasting is seen as a 'poor decision' that detracts from the show's quality, with some fans wishing for Henry Cavill's return.
Positive/Mixed Fan Reactions
Despite the recasting, some viewers remain engaged with the series, appreciating the continuation of the story and the addition of new characters like Regis.
- Show
- The Witcher
- Streaming Platform
- Netflix
- New Geralt Actor
- Liam Hemsworth
- Previous Geralt Actor
- Henry Cavill
- Season Premiered
- Thursday
- New Cast Members
- Laurence Fishburne as Regis, Sharlto Copley as Leo Bonhart, James Purefoy as Skellen, Danny Woodburn as Zoltan