4 days ago
High Court Dismisses BSF Beard Retirement Plea on Jurisdiction
Khursheed Ahmad Khan was a Border Security Force soldier who was allowed to keep a neatly trimmed beard.
The force said his beard later became too long and untidy, and that he refused to trim it.
Khan said this led him to ask for retirement because he felt pressured.
The Border Security Force said he chose retirement freely and denied being forced.
His retirement request was accepted on June 16, 2023.
He later tried to withdraw it, but that request was rejected.
The Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court said it was not the right court to hear the case because the important events happened in Meghalaya.
Khan can still take his complaint to the court with the correct territorial jurisdiction.
Khursheed Ahmad Khan challenged his retirement from the Border Security Force after permission to keep a trimmed beard was revoked.
The Border Security Force said Khan had appeared with a long, free-flowing beard and refused to trim it on June 16, 2023.
Khan said the beard-permission withdrawal forced him to seek voluntary retirement, while the force said he applied willingly and denied pressure.
The Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court did not decide whether the beard action or retirement was legally valid.
The court dismissed the petition because the relevant events occurred in Meghalaya, allowing Khan to approach the appropriate jurisdictional court.
- Who
- Khursheed Ahmad Khan and the Border Security Force.
- What
- A court dismissed Khan’s challenge to his voluntary retirement and the related beard-permission dispute because it lacked territorial jurisdiction.
- Where
- The retirement decision was made at the 50th Battalion Border Security Force location in Praharinagar, Tura, Meghalaya; the petition was heard in Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh.
- When
- The retirement events occurred on June 16, 2023; the High Court dismissed the petition on September 30.
- Why
- The High Court found that no material part of the cause of action arose within Jammu and Kashmir.
Khan’s Account
Border Security Force’s Account
Reason for retirement request
Khan’s Account
Khan said the withdrawal of permission to maintain his beard prompted him to seek voluntary retirement and that he was compelled to do so.
Border Security Force’s Account
The Border Security Force said Khan expressed a desire to retire, submitted the application himself, and denied being under pressure when questioned by the commandant.
Beard dispute
Khan’s Account
Khan alleged that permission to keep his beard was cancelled vindictively and that the decision was connected to his retirement.
Border Security Force’s Account
The force said he was found with a long, free-flowing beard, was improperly dressed, and refused to trim it despite permission requiring a neat, trimmed beard.
Court jurisdiction
Khan’s Account
Khan argued that the presence of senior Border Security Force officials connected to Kashmir and New Delhi allowed the Jammu and Kashmir court to hear the petition.
Border Security Force’s Account
The force argued that the retirement order and application were handled in Meghalaya, and the court agreed that no material part of the cause of action arose in Jammu and Kashmir.
Key facts
- Petitioner
- Khursheed Ahmad Khan
- Force
- Border Security Force
- Retirement date
- June 16, 2023
- Beard permission
- Granted on January 6, 2018, subject to the beard remaining neat and properly trimmed
- Court outcome
- Petition dismissed for want of territorial jurisdiction
- Retirement withdrawal
- Khan’s June 17, 2023 request to withdraw the application was rejected
- Further legal option
- The court left Khan free to approach the appropriate jurisdictional court
Sources
Related news
High Court Orders Reinstatement of Disengaged Jammu and Kashmir SPO
Veterans Urge Modi to Reinstate 400 Dismissed BSF Jawans
Chhattisgarh High Court Upholds CRPF Constable’s Removal
Supreme Court Stays Reinstatement in IAS Dog-Walk Row
High Court Orders Reinstatement After Judge Resigns Over Son’s Care
Odisha Court Reinstates Judicial Officer Who Resigned Over Son’s Treatment
Southwest Monsoon Yet To Withdraw As Northeast Records Rainfall Deficit
Maharashtra Launches 1,000-Day Mission for Integrated Early Childhood Development
Meghalaya Police Opens Inquiry Into Alleged Truck Bribes
Meghalaya Records 60 Percent Monsoon Rainfall Deficit, IMD Says
Meghalaya Plans AI and GCC Push to Attract Tech Firms
