Archive · 29 Nov 2025
Medical Negligence Cases Face Delays in Telangana
A woman named Maheshwari had a surgery at a hospital in Hyderabad.
After the surgery, she felt very bad pain in her stomach.
Doctors found a pair of scissors left inside her from a previous surgery.
The family reported this to the police, and a case was started.
But, the case has been going on for almost five years.
The police say they need a special report from doctors to prove that the hospital was very careless.
This takes a long time.
Some people think that doctors should decide these cases instead of the police and courts.
This way, it might be faster and easier for everyone.
A surgical scissor was left in Maheshwari's abdomen during a surgery at NIMS in 2019, leading to a medical negligence case.
The case has been under trial for nearly five years due to delays in obtaining a medical board report.
Police require a medical board report to confirm gross negligence before proceeding with arrests or chargesheets.
The Supreme Court's verdict in Jacob Mathew vs State of Punjab (2005) states that doctors can face criminal action only if there is clear proof of reckless treatment.
The Indian Medical Association (IMA) suggests that medical negligence cases should be examined by medical councils rather than courts to expedite the process.
- Who
- Maheshwari, a patient who had a surgical scissor left in her abdomen, and the medical professionals involved in her treatment.
- What
- A case of medical negligence where a surgical scissor was left in a patient's abdomen during a surgery, leading to prolonged legal proceedings.
- When
- The incident occurred in 2019, and the case has been under trial for nearly five years.
- Where
- The incident took place at Nizam's Institute of Medical Sciences (NIMS) in Hyderabad, Telangana.
- Why
- The case faces delays due to the requirement of a medical board report to confirm gross negligence before arrests or chargesheets can be made.
- Patient
- Maheshwari
- Hospital
- Nizam's Institute of Medical Sciences (NIMS)
- Year of Incident
- 2019
- Current Case Status
- Under trial
- Legal Requirement
- Medical board report for prosecution
- Supreme Court Verdict
- Jacob Mathew vs State of Punjab (2005)
- IMA Chairman
- Dr Sanjeev Singh Yadav
