Archive · 20 Sep 2025
Punjab Court Debates Desilting of Rivers Amidst Sand Mining Concerns
Imagine the government is cleaning out rivers to help prevent floods, like tidying up your room.
Some people are worried the government is actually taking sand from the rivers to sell it, which is like taking your toys and selling them.
They argue this needs special permission.
The government says they're just cleaning to keep the rivers safe and prevent flooding.
The people asking the questions are also pointing out that it's taking a long time to start the cleaning and that the rules for doing it might not be followed.
The court is listening to both sides to decide what's really happening.
The Punjab and Haryana High Court heard arguments on the state's river desilting policy.
Senior Advocate Garry questioned if desilting is a cover for sand mining.
Garry cited that revenue generation from desilting sites indicates commercial intent.
AG Bedi asserted desilting is purely for flood mitigation and river capacity restoration.
The bench indicated it would pass an interim order after hearing both sides.
- Who
- Senior Advocate Gurminder Singh Garry and Punjab Advocate General M.S. Bedi
- What
- Debate over Punjab's river desilting policy
- When
- Friday
- Where
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
- Why
- To determine if desilting is a flood control measure or sand mining operation.
Concerns Over Sand Mining
Flood Mitigation and River Maintenance
Purpose of Desilting
Concerns Over Sand Mining
Desilting is a cover for commercial sand mining, bypassing environmental safeguards.
Flood Mitigation and River Maintenance
Desilting is solely for flood prevention and river maintenance.
Compliance with Rules
Concerns Over Sand Mining
The government is not following the 2013 Punjab Minor Mineral Rules and national sand mining guidelines.
Flood Mitigation and River Maintenance
The government will adhere to all conditions and prepare detailed project reports.
- Case
- Punjab and Haryana High Court hearing
- Parties Involved
- Senior Advocate Gurminder Singh Garry, Punjab AG M.S. Bedi
- Issue
- Desilting policy questioned as sand mining
- Rivers Mentioned
- Sutlej and Ravi
- Legal Frameworks Cited
- Punjab Minor Mineral Rules 2013, National Framework for Sediment Management 2022
- Government's Stance
- Desilting is for flood mitigation and river maintenance