Archive · 6 Jan 2026
Mamata Banerjee to Challenge SIR Process in Court
Mamata Banerjee, the Chief Minister of West Bengal, is very worried about how the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) process for updating voter lists is being done.
She says important instructions are sent through WhatsApp and text messages instead of official documents, and there are problems with training and IT systems.
She asked the Election Commission to fix these problems or stop the process.
Suvendu Adhikari, the Leader of Opposition, says the SIR is a good plan to clean up the voter lists and that the IT systems are working well.
He thinks Banerjee is trying to stop the process because it might show problems in the voter lists that her party has benefited from.
Banerjee also said she will go to court to challenge the SIR process, and she might even go to the Supreme Court if needed.
She is worried about the hardship faced by elderly, disabled, and vulnerable voters who have to travel long distances and lose income to prove they are legitimate voters.
The Election Commission has found many cases of logical discrepancies, excluded voters, and unmapped voters.
Cricketer Mohammed Shami and his brother were also summoned for a hearing due to discrepancies in their enumeration forms.
Mamata Banerjee plans to challenge the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) process in court, possibly going to the Supreme Court.
She alleges the SIR process is flawed due to informal communication, inadequate training, and defective IT systems, causing hardship to vulnerable voters.
Suvendu Adhikari defends the SIR process, stating it is well-planned and the IT systems are functioning well, accusing Banerjee of political desperation.
The Election Commission has found 91.46 lakh cases of logical discrepancy, 58.20 lakh excluded voters, and 30 lakh unmapped voters during the SIR.
Mohammed Shami and his brother were summoned for a hearing due to discrepancies in their enumeration forms, but Shami could not attend due to a cricket match.
- Who
- Mamata Banerjee, Chief Minister of West Bengal, and Suvendu Adhikari, Leader of Opposition in West Bengal
- What
- A clash over the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) process of electoral rolls in West Bengal
- When
- Letter dated January 3, with responses from Adhikari on January 6
- Where
- West Bengal, India
- Why
- Concerns over the integrity and transparency of the SIR process, with political implications for the 2026 assembly elections
Mamata Banerjee's Concerns
Suvendu Adhikari's Counterarguments
Process Integrity
Mamata Banerjee's Concerns
Mamata Banerjee claims the SIR process is flawed due to informal communication, inadequate training, and defective IT systems, leading to potential disenfranchisement.
Suvendu Adhikari's Counterarguments
Suvendu Adhikari asserts that the SIR is a well-planned national initiative to clean up electoral rolls, and the IT systems have processed millions of entries seamlessly.
Communication Methods
Mamata Banerjee's Concerns
Banerjee argues that critical instructions are being communicated informally via WhatsApp and text messages, lacking transparency and accountability.
Suvendu Adhikari's Counterarguments
Adhikari defends the use of digital channels like WhatsApp for urgent clarifications, stating that this hybrid model enhances responsiveness without sacrificing accountability.
Impact on Voters
Mamata Banerjee's Concerns
Banerjee expresses concerns about the hardship faced by migrant workers, elderly, infirm, and seriously ill citizens being called for hearings.
Suvendu Adhikari's Counterarguments
Adhikari dismisses these claims as exaggerated propaganda, stating that such hardships are rare occurrences.
Political Motives
Mamata Banerjee's Concerns
Banerjee urges the Election Commission to address the issues or halt the SIR process to prevent irreparable damage and disenfranchisement.
Suvendu Adhikari's Counterarguments
Adhikari accuses Banerjee of political desperation and a frantic bid to derail the SIR, which threatens to expose the rot in the electoral rolls nurtured by her party.
Use of Official Letterhead
Mamata Banerjee's Concerns
Banerjee used her official letterhead as Chief Minister to raise concerns about the SIR process.
Suvendu Adhikari's Counterarguments
Adhikari argues that using the official letterhead for political contentions is illegal and unconstitutional, and the letter should be treated as trash.
- Person Involved
- Mamata Banerjee, Chief Minister of West Bengal
- Recipient of Letter
- Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar
- Date of Letter
- January 3
- Process in Question
- Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls
- Alleged Issues
- Informal communication, lack of transparency, inadequate training, defective IT systems
- Counterarguments
- Suvendu Adhikari's defense of the SIR process and IT systems
- Political Context
- Concerns over the impact of SIR on the 2026 assembly elections
- Legal Concerns
- Use of official letterhead for political contentions
- Logical Discrepancies
- 91.46 lakh cases of logical discrepancy found by the Election Commission
- Excluded Voters
- 58.20 lakh excluded voters and 30 lakh unmapped voters
- Cricketer Involved
- Mohammed Shami and his brother summoned for SIR hearing
- Bridge Project
- Gangasagar Setu bridge project worth Rs 1,670 crore
Sources
CM Mamata writes to CEC over ‘procedural violations, administrative lapses’ in SIR process
Suvendu Adhikari writes to CEC slamming Mamata Banerjee’s SIR concerns: ‘Designed to malign poll panel as politically motivated’
Suvendu Adhikari hits back at Mamata over Bengal SIR: ‘Call to halt an admission of defeat’
Bengal LoP questions Mamata’s use of CM letterhead to raise Trinamool’s issues
Meet the foot soldiers of Indian citizenship in Bengal who help Hindus from Bangladesh
Suvendu Adhikari writes to CEC, rebuts CM Mamata Banerjee’s claims on SIR in Bengal
Bengal SIR: 14 voters with Indian EPIC cards found holding Bangladeshi passports; CEO asks for deletion
Mamata says she will move court on Tuesday against ‘inhumane’ conduct of SIR
Mamata to Move Court on Tuesday Over ‘Inhumane’ Conduct of SIR
Will Seek Legal Help: Mamata Banerjee Says Can Go To Supreme Court On SIR
Cricketer Mohammed Shami, His Brother Summoned By EC For SIR Hearing In Kolkata
‘AI weaponised to disenfranchise millions’: Mamata says she’ll move Supreme Court over SIR discrepancies as an ‘ordinary citizen’
Mamata Banerjee to move court on Tuesday against ‘inhumane’ electoral roll revision in Bengal
Mamata Flags ‘Deaths, Fear and Inhumane Treatment' in SIR, Says Will Move Supreme Court
Mamata says will move court on Jan 6 against ‘arbitrary’ SIR, human sufferings
Mamata Banerjee To Move Court Against 'Inhumane Treatment' Of People During Bengal SIR; BJP Reacts
ECI ignoring domicile certificates issued by West Bengal govt as they were granted illegally: Adhikari
ECI holds meeting on assembly elections amid demand for increased Central forces for Bengal
Mamata to move court on Jan 6 against ‘arbitrary’ SIR, flags human suffering; BJP hits back
SIR Used To 'Harass Bengal', Will Move Court Against 'Inhumane' Conduct: Mamata Banerjee
Didi Dares To Move SC Against SIR
No central funds for Gangasagar Mela despite global footfall: Mamata
‘Inadvertent errors’ led to deletion of voters’ names flagged by TMC, says EC
Actor Dev gets SIR notice, TMC says EC deliberately harassing three-term MP
Mamata to move court against SIR
UP SIR Draft Roll LIVE Updates: Election Commission to release draft SIR electoral roll 2026 today; nearly 3 crore names likely to be deleted
Assam Congress flags ‘serious irregularities’ in draft voter rolls, seeks freeze ahead of polls
Bengal Poll Officer Stands In Queue For Voter Verification, Sparks Row
Trinamool Congress Moves Supreme Court Against Election Commission Over SIR