Archive · 8 Dec 2025
Lessons from Latin America for India's History Debates
The article discusses how history is used to justify political ideologies in India and Latin America.
In India, Hindutva politics often highlights the supposed barbarism of medieval rulers like Aurangzeb to promote a narrative of Hindu superiority.
Similarly, in Latin America, European colonisers used accounts of indigenous cruelty, like the Aztecs' human sacrifices, to justify their conquest.
The article contrasts this with the New and Post-New Left movements in Latin America, which use history to promote inclusive governance and participatory politics.
These movements emphasize indigenous rights and collective empowerment, showing that history can be used to build fairer societies rather than to exclude and oppress.
The author argues that India can learn from these examples to foster a more inclusive public imagination and strengthen democratic participation.
Hindutva politics in India often portrays medieval rulers like Aurangzeb as barbaric to justify exclusionary policies.
European colonisers in Latin America used accounts of indigenous cruelty to morally justify their conquest.
The Aztecs practised human sacrifice, while other indigenous groups like the Maya and Inca performed sacrifices rarely.
Latin America's New and Post-New Left movements use history to promote inclusive governance and participatory politics.
These movements emphasize indigenous rights and collective empowerment, contrasting with the exclusionary narratives of Hindutva politics.
- Who
- Sahasranshu Dash, research associate at the International Centre for Applied Ethics and Public Affairs in Sheffield, UK
- What
- An analysis of how historical narratives are used to justify political ideologies in India and Latin America
- When
- Present-day debates and historical context from the medieval period to contemporary politics
- Where
- India and Latin America
- Why
- To highlight the weaponisation of history and the potential for inclusive governance and participatory politics
- Aztec Practices
- Human sacrifice, ritualised warfare, and harsh punishments
- Maya, Zapotec, Mixtec, and Inca Practices
- Rare sacrifices for symbolic or cosmological reasons
- Spanish Theologians
- Juan Ginés de Sepúlveda argued conquest was a civilising mission; Bartolomé de las Casas defended indigenous rationality
- Hindutva Discourse
- Selectively highlights mosque-building, Persianate culture, and Aurangzeb’s campaigns as evidence of cruelty
- Latin America's New and Post-New Left
- Combines historical memory, indigenous knowledge, and participatory politics
- Zapatistas
- Redefined democracy through indigenous cosmologies, aiming for participatory governance
- Claudia Sheinbaum
- Declared 2025 as the 'Year of the Indigenous Woman', restored sacred lands to Wixárika communities
- Pedro Castillo
- Faced violent opposition while trying to empower rural and indigenous communities