Archive · 17 Aug 2025
Centre Challenges Court Deadlines for Approving Bills
The Indian government doesn't want the Supreme Court to set deadlines for the President and Governors to approve bills.
The government believes the court shouldn't make these rules because the Constitution doesn't say there have to be deadlines.
The government is worried that if the court sets deadlines it could create problems for how the government works.
The Supreme Court is going to listen to arguments about this situation.
The Centre opposes the Supreme Court imposing deadlines on Governors and the President for bill approval.
The government argues that setting fixed timelines could lead to 'constitutional disorder'.
Solicitor General Tushar Mehta states that the Constitution gives Governors and the President discretion without time limits.
The Supreme Court is hearing the matter after a Presidential Reference.
The court's hearing on the case is set to begin on Tuesday.
- Who
- The Centre, Supreme Court, President, Governors, and Solicitor General are involved.
- What
- The Centre is opposing the Supreme Court's potential imposition of deadlines on Governors and the President for approving bills.
- When
- The Supreme Court will begin hearing the Presidential Reference on Tuesday.
- Where
- India
- Why
- The Centre believes that imposing timelines would lead to constitutional disorder.
Government's View
Supreme Court's View
Judicial Overreach vs. Constitutional Balance
Government's View
Judicial intervention could upset the balance of power and lead to a 'constitutional disorder'.
Supreme Court's View
The Supreme Court is considering imposing deadlines on the President and Governors regarding bills.
- Government's Stance
- Opposes judicial timelines for bill approval
- Solicitor General
- Tushar Mehta
- Key Argument
- Imposing timelines would disrupt constitutional balance and lead to disorder
- Articles Mentioned
- Articles 200 and 201, Article 142, Article 143(1)
- Court's Action
- Hearing the Presidential Reference
- Related Case
- Tamil Nadu vs. Governor RN Ravi
Sources
Centre Warns Of "Constitutional Chaos" After Timeline Order For Governors
Centre cautions the SC against overstepping its powers and defeating the intent of the constitution makers
'Will Result in Constitutional Chaos': Centre Opposes SC Deadlines for President, Governors to Act on State Bills
Imposing fixed timelines on Guvs, Prez would lead to ‘constitutional disorder’: Centre to SC
‘Can’t assume powers Constitution has not vested’: Centre warns Supreme Court against judicial overreach
Centre Opposes Deadlines for President, Governors to Act on Bills
Centre opposes Supreme Court ‘deadline’ for President, governors, warns against judicial overreach: ‘Nothing in Constitution…’
Deadlines for Guvs, Prez on Bills risk constitutional disorder: Centre to SC
Setting deadlines for president, governors can cause ‘constitutional disorder’: Centre tells SC