Archive · 19 Sep 2025
Judge Scolds Lima Over Brookfield Toll Dispute
Imagine the city of Lima has been fighting a company called Brookfield over a toll road.
Lima's mayor thinks the contract for the road was made unfairly, maybe with a bribe.
They've lost in court and owe Brookfield money.
The mayor doesn't want to pay.
A judge is now looking at the case again, and she is not happy with Lima's arguments.
She thinks they are just trying to delay paying.
The company that built the road originally admitted to bribing people elsewhere but denies doing so in this case.
The mayor keeps saying he won’t pay, which annoys the judge even more.
There's a lot of legal back and forth, but the city is losing ground.
Lima is attempting to overturn $200 million in arbitration losses related to a toll contract.
A US federal judge expressed strong skepticism toward Lima's arguments.
The city alleges the toll contract was initially obtained through bribery.
Mayor Rafael Lopez Aliaga has made canceling the contract a priority.
Brookfield has also filed for $2.7 billion in damages and against Peruvian court decisions.
- Who
- Lima, represented by Mayor Rafael Lopez Aliaga, and Brookfield Asset Management
- What
- Legal battle over a toll contract, with Lima attempting to overturn arbitration losses.
- When
- Thursday's hearing (no specific date mentioned), ongoing for years.
- Where
- US federal court in Washington, involving a contract in Peru.
- Why
- Lima alleges the toll contract was obtained through bribery, and refuses to pay arbitration losses.
City of Lima
Brookfield Asset Management
Payment of Arbitration Awards
City of Lima
Refuses to pay the $200 million arbitration award.
Brookfield Asset Management
Demands payment of the $200 million arbitration award.
Validity of Toll Contract
City of Lima
Claims the toll contract was obtained through bribery and is therefore invalid.
Brookfield Asset Management
Maintains the validity of the toll contract, despite bribery allegations against the original contractor, and seeks damages.
- Parties Involved
- Lima, Brookfield Asset Management, Odebrecht SA
- Disputed Amount
- $200 million in arbitration losses (unpaid)
- Location
- US federal court in Washington
- Toll Contract Origin
- Allegations of bribery in the early 2010s
- Lima's Mayor
- Rafael Lopez Aliaga (Porky)