1 hr ago
Vembu Defends India’s Competition Record Amid Musk’s Starlink Criticism
Sridhar Vembu says people in India can get cheap mobile data, medicines and digital payments.
He says competition, including Jio’s entry into mobile services, helped make some of these things affordable.
Elon Musk says business interests are holding back Starlink, his satellite internet company, from operating in India.
India’s government says its rules are fair and do not treat satellite companies differently.
Starlink has a telecom licence, but that alone is not enough to start service.
It must pass security checks and receive permission to use spectrum.
Eutelsat OneWeb and Jio Satellite Communications also have licences.
The government says the security assessments are still underway.
Zoho founder Sridhar Vembu cited low data prices, affordable medicines and inexpensive UPI payments as evidence of consumer benefits from competition.
Vembu credited Reliance Jio’s launch with driving down Indian mobile data prices and praised the government’s support for competition and startups.
Elon Musk alleged that business interests were blocking Starlink’s entry into India and questioned the delay in its approval.
India’s Ministry of Communications called claims of a discriminatory framework baseless and said security assessments for satellite services were underway.
Starlink, Eutelsat OneWeb and Jio Satellite Communications have telecom licences, but must meet security conditions and obtain spectrum before commercial operations.
- Who
- Zoho founder Sridhar Vembu, Elon Musk, and India’s Ministry of Communications.
- What
- Vembu defended India’s competition record after Musk alleged business interests were blocking Starlink’s entry; the government rejected the allegation.
- Where
- India; the statements were made on X.
- When
- Musk posted his allegations on Wednesday and Thursday; the government issued its response on Thursday, and Vembu responded in a post on X.
- Why
- Musk questioned the delay in Starlink’s approval, while Vembu argued that competition has benefited Indian consumers.
Government and Vembu
Musk
Fairness of India’s satellite-service rules
Government and Vembu
The Ministry of Communications said India’s authorisation framework is fair and non-discriminatory, and described the allegation of discriminatory treatment as baseless.
Musk
Musk alleged that business interests were blocking Starlink and questioned why it had not received approval despite complying with requirements.
Competition and consumer benefits
Government and Vembu
Vembu argued that competition has helped deliver low data prices, affordable medicines and low-cost payments, and said the government encourages competition and startups.
Musk
Musk argued that Starlink should be allowed to compete and said its service could help people in areas without internet access.
Key facts
- Vembu’s examples
- Low mobile data prices, affordable medicines and low-cost UPI payments.
- Company Vembu credited
- Reliance Jio, whose launch he said was directly responsible for low data prices.
- Musk’s allegation
- He claimed business interests were blocking Starlink’s entry into India.
- Government response
- The Ministry of Communications called the allegation baseless and said India has a fair, non-discriminatory authorisation framework.
- Licensed satellite service providers named
- Starlink, Eutelsat OneWeb and Jio Satellite Communications.
- Requirements before commercial service
- Security conditions must be met and spectrum must be assigned.
- Status of assessments
- The government said security assessments were underway.
Quotes
Sridhar Vembu
Founder of Zoho who commented on India's competition and consumer prices.
“India has the among the lowest data prices in the world. It is so good that I don't even bother to connect to local Wifi when I travel in India and just tether my phone to work on my computer. Indians routinely have dual SIM phones with large data plans because they are so affordable. Ambani's launch of Jio is directly responsible for the low data prices Indians enjoy.”
livemint.com
“Unfortunately, we are being blocked by certain oligarchs in order to maintain their monopolistic chokehold on the Indian people. You can guess who they are... This is a crime against the people of India!”
livemint.com
Ministry of Communications
Indian government ministry responsible for communications.
“The Government has put in place a fair and non-discriminatory authorisation framework for all telecommunication services, including satellite communication services.”
livemint.com
Sources
Related news
Musk Calls Ambani ‘Prime Minister’ in Starlink India Dispute
Musk Questions Ambani as Starlink Awaits India Security Clearance
Musk, Rahul Gandhi Trade Posts Over Starlink’s India Entry
Musk Renews Starlink Pitch as India Reviews Security Clearances
Musk Accuses ‘Oligarchs’ of Blocking Starlink’s India Launch
Kamal Haasan Says India, Not Billionaires, Decides Starlink Policy
Starlink Delay Raises Security Questions, Not Monopoly Proof
India Nears Finalisation of Satellite Spectrum Pricing Framework
Reliance Jio Builds Technology Stack Ahead of Proposed IPO
Ram Madhav Says Starlink Spectrum Decision Will Follow Law
