Archive · 16 Nov 2025
Chinese Primary School Faces Criticism for Student Car Salutes
At a school in China, children were made to stand outside in the cold to salute their teachers' cars as they arrived.
The school said it was a way to teach them good manners.
However, some parents were unhappy because their kids had to wake up much earlier.
They felt the children should be sleeping or learning instead of standing in the cold.
A video of this practice went viral, leading to many people talking about whether it was a good idea.
Some teachers did wave back, but others didn't seem to notice the students.
The practice has caused a lot of discussion online and among parents.
Students at Jianqiao Primary School in China were filmed saluting teachers' cars on cold mornings.
The school described the practice as 'etiquette education' to teach respect.
Some parents complained that their children had to wake up earlier for the practice.
Reports indicate that not all teachers acknowledged the students' salutes.
The incident has sparked widespread discussion online regarding its appropriateness.
- Who
- Students at Jianqiao Primary School
- What
- Students were seen saluting teachers' cars on cold winter mornings.
- When
- During cold winter mornings.
- Where
- Jianqiao Primary School in Hangzhou, Zhejiang province, China.
- Why
- The school stated it was 'etiquette education' to teach respect, though parents raised concerns about early wake-up times and standing in the cold.
Supporters of the Practice
Critics of the Practice
Educational Value and Respect
Supporters of the Practice
The school described the practice as 'etiquette education' aimed at teaching students respect and politeness.
Critics of the Practice
Critics argue that forcing children to stand in the cold to salute cars is unnecessary and a poor use of their time. Parents expressed concern that it interferes with children's sleep, requiring them to wake up earlier.
Teacher Acknowledgment
Supporters of the Practice
Some teachers were observed waving to the students.
Critics of the Practice
Several vehicles drove past without acknowledging the students' salutes, diminishing the perceived value of the practice.
- School Name
- Jianqiao Primary School
- Location
- Hangzhou, Zhejiang province, China
- Practice
- Students salute arriving teachers' cars in the morning.
- Reason for Practice (School's View)
- Etiquette education to teach respect.
- Student Organization Symbol
- Young Pioneers salute
