Archive · 23 Aug 2025
Salve: Jailed Officials Shouldn't Run Their Offices
India is discussing a new law.
This law says that if a high-ranking official gets arrested and stays in jail for more than 30 days, they can't keep their job.
Lawyer Harish Salve agrees.
He thinks it is wrong to run the government from jail and it weakens democracy.
He also mentions that in the past, people in similar situations would step down from their positions.
Salve believes that this new law is necessary to maintain public trust.
Harish Salve supports a bill to remove ministers arrested for over 30 days.
Salve argues that holding office from prison undermines democracy.
He contrasts current views with those of past leaders who resigned upon being charged.
The bill, introduced by Home Minister Amit Shah, is for the 130th Amendment.
Salve believes the judiciary can distinguish between false and true cases.
- Who
- Harish Salve, Indian politicians, and the Indian judiciary.
- What
- The 130th Constitutional Amendment Bill proposes removing ministers in custody over 30 days.
- When
- Ongoing
- Where
- India
- Why
- To preserve democratic values and public trust in government.
Arguments Against the Bill
Government Stance
Potential for Abuse
Arguments Against the Bill
Bill may be misused for political targeting.
Government Stance
Bill aims to prevent office from jail.
- Bill Subject
- Constitution (130th Amendment) Bill
- Key Provision
- Removal of ministers in custody over 30 days
- Advocate's Stance
- Harish Salve supports the bill
- Main Argument
- Office cannot be run from jail
Sources
Assam CM supports 130th Constitution Amendment Bill, calls it a step to 'restore faith in governance'
Bill is about decriminalisation of politics, not about Nitish: Shambhavi Choudhary hits back at Tejashwi
Bill for removal of arrested ministers offers promise of clean governance, reflects will of people
PM pans TMC, INDIA bloc; vows to oust infiltrators, bar holding office from jail
Shah defends 130th Constitutional Amendment Bill, cites Kejriwal’s refusal to resign while jailed
PM Modi, Amit Shah attack Oppn for criticising Bill seeking dismissal of tainted politicians
"Politicians Think They Are Privileged Class": Harish Salve On Bill To Sack Ministers