1 hr ago
Delayed Train Wait Leads to ₹500 Platform Ticket Fine
A man went to Kalyan station to help his family catch a train.
He bought a platform ticket so he could go onto the platform.
The train was delayed, so the family had to wait longer than expected.
When the man was leaving at about 5 PM, a railway official asked to see his ticket.
The man was told it was valid for only two hours and was fined ₹500.
People online disagreed about whether the fine was fair.
Some said the railway should not punish people for waiting because of a delay.
Others said platform tickets have a fixed time limit.
The report says the claims in the original social media post were not independently verified.
A man was reportedly fined ₹500 at Kalyan railway station after his platform ticket expired.
He had accompanied his family to the station and was helping them board their train.
The train was initially expected at noon, then reportedly delayed until around 2 PM and later still delayed.
The man said he was stopped around 5 PM and told platform tickets are valid for two hours.
Online reactions were divided, with some criticizing the fine and others saying the ticket’s time limit still applied.
- Who
- A man accompanying his family, and a TTE who reportedly checked his platform ticket.
- What
- The man was reportedly fined ₹500 after his platform ticket expired while he waited with his family.
- Where
- Kalyan railway station, Maharashtra, India.
- When
- The incident was reported in a post dated October 3, 2026; the article was updated October 4, 2026.
- Why
- According to the report, more than two hours had passed since the man bought his platform ticket.
Critics of the fine
Defenders of the time limit
Responsibility for the extended wait
Critics of the fine
Some commenters argued the man should not be penalized for staying longer because the train was delayed, and suggested passengers should be compensated.
Defenders of the time limit
Other commenters said a platform ticket has a fixed validity period that is not tied to a specific train, so the man should have bought another ticket.
How to handle a prolonged delay
Critics of the fine
Critics said the railway should account for passengers and family members forced to wait because of delays.
Defenders of the time limit
One commenter suggested buying a local train ticket to the next station instead of a platform ticket when a train is running late.
Key facts
- Reported fine
- ₹500
- Station
- Kalyan railway station
- Platform ticket validity
- Two hours, according to the report and cited comments
- Train's original departure time
- 12 noon
- Revised expected arrival
- Around 2 PM
- Reported time of ticket check
- Around 5 PM
- Railway response
- RailwaySeva said the concerned authorities were being informed.
- Verification
- News18 said the original post's claims had not been independently verified.
Quotes
RailwaySeva
Official railway customer-service account that responded to the post.
“It is stupid question to ask. Platform ticket has no binding with any specific train. It has only time limit. He should have bought another one. TTE not fined his parents. Cause reservation is done against specific train.”
news18.com
“Actually, in any civilised country, the Railways should have been penalized for the delay.. But in our country, we are penalized for the inefficient services of the Railways”
news18.com
Sources
Related news
Railways Ordered to Pay Rs 35,000 After Train Delay
Jharkhand Consumer Court Orders Railways to Pay ₹35,000
Railway UPI Tickets Above Rs 2,000 Face Rs 5 MDR
Railway Constable Rescues Passenger From Moving Train Gap
Passenger Climbs Train at Renigunta, Reaches for Power Wires
Central Railway Intensifies Ticket Checks Throughout October
BJP Names Three Candidates for Maharashtra Legislative Council Polls
Thackeray Cousins Lead Mumbai Protest Against Maharashtra SIR
Pawar Backs Wider Action as Thackerays Protest Election Chief
Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar Among Top Districts Honored Under PM Scheme
