Archive · 28 Aug 2026
Nadda Engages Anti-Reservation Protesters Amid BJP’s Upper-Caste Dilemma
Some protesters want reservations to be based more on a person’s income than on caste.
They say this should apply to education and government jobs.
They also say they do not want to take away protections for SC, ST and OBC communities.
J.P. Nadda met some of the protesters and said they had a friendly discussion.
He did not explain what was agreed or whether their demands would be accepted.
Brajesh Pathak had also met the group and said he would pass their concerns to the BJP’s central leaders.
Observers believe the BJP is trying to reassure upper-caste voters.
They also say changing the reservation system would be very difficult politically.
Union Minister J.P. Nadda held “cordial discussions” with members of the Reservation Hatao Andolan.
The group wants caste-based quotas in education and government jobs replaced with income-based reservations.
The protesters said their campaign would not infringe on SC, ST and OBC rights.
Uttar Pradesh Deputy Chief Minister Brajesh Pathak had earlier said he would raise their demands with the BJP’s central leadership.
Observers view the outreach as an effort to address upper-caste concerns while avoiding changes to the politically sensitive reservation system.
- Who
- Union Minister J.P. Nadda, Uttar Pradesh Deputy Chief Minister Brajesh Pathak, and members of the Reservation Hatao Andolan.
- What
- Nadda met anti-reservation protesters who are seeking greater emphasis on income-based quotas instead of caste-based reservations.
- When
- The meeting took place after the group’s Jantar Mantar protest on 21 August; the article does not provide the meeting’s exact date.
- Where
- The protest was held at Jantar Mantar; Nadda’s meeting location is not specified.
- Why
- The outreach followed the group’s demands and growing activity, while observers say the BJP is responding to concerns among upper-caste voters.
Protesters’ Position
BJP’s Reported Approach
Basis for reservations
Protesters’ Position
The protesters want economic disadvantage to receive greater weight and caste-based reservations to be replaced by income-based quotas.
BJP’s Reported Approach
Observers say the BJP is engaging with the demand but understands that changing the reservation system is politically difficult.
Effect on protected communities
Protesters’ Position
The group says its movement is not intended to encroach on the rights of Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes.
BJP’s Reported Approach
The article does not report a detailed BJP position on how the protesters’ proposal would affect SC, ST and OBC reservations.
Purpose of the meetings
Protesters’ Position
Protesters reportedly warned they would hold a larger Jantar Mantar gathering if their demands were not addressed.
BJP’s Reported Approach
Observers describe the meetings with Nadda and Pathak as an effort to reassure upper-caste voters and show that party leaders are listening, without committing to reform.
- Protest group
- Reservation Hatao Andolan
- Main demand
- Replace caste-based reservations in education and government jobs with income-based quotas.
- Nadda’s statement
- He described the discussions with protesters as “cordial” and said the sides would meet again soon.
- Earlier outreach
- Brajesh Pathak reportedly assured protesters that he would take their demands to the BJP’s central leadership.
- Protest location
- Jantar Mantar
- States where the movement is gaining traction
- Uttar Pradesh, Uttarakhand and Bihar
- Political context
- Observers link the outreach to upper-caste concerns, including opposition to the now-stayed UGC equity regulations.