Archive · 3 Dec 2025
DOGE's Failure Highlights Bureaucratic Efficiency Debate
The Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) in the US was created to make the government work better by cutting waste and firing many workers.
But it didn't work well and was shut down.
Some people in India thought we should have something like DOGE to fix our slow and inefficient bureaucracy.
However, the article says that the real problem in India is not too many bureaucrats but too few.
It also warns that just using technology and algorithms to make things efficient can be dangerous.
The state is not like a business, and efficiency should not come at the cost of democracy and social justice.
The article suggests that making the Indian state more efficient means hiring more people and making the state more democratic and accountable to its citizens.
DOGE was a US initiative to improve government efficiency by reducing waste, fraud, and abuse, but it was disbanded after 10 months.
DOGE fired an estimated 260,000 federal workers, but its approach was criticized as dystopian and inefficient.
In India, debates on bureaucratic efficiency often focus on technology and surveillance, but these can burden frontline workers.
The Indian state is understaffed, with significant shortages in key positions, making efficiency through hiring more officials necessary.
Efficiency in government should balance equity, justice, and social stability, not just cost-effectiveness and market principles.
- Who
- Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), Indian bureaucracy
- What
- DOGE's failure and debate on bureaucratic efficiency
- When
- DOGE was active for 10 months, disbanded recently
- Where
- United States and India
- Why
- To improve government efficiency and reduce waste, fraud, and abuse
- DOGE
- Department of Government Efficiency
- DOGE's Goal
- Improve efficiency by reducing waste, fraud, and abuse
- DOGE's Outcome
- Disbanded after 10 months, fired 260,000 federal workers
- Indian Bureaucracy
- Understaffed, needs more hiring for efficiency
- Government Employment in India
- 4.6% of total employment (2011)
- Government Employment in US
- 15.9% of total employment
- Government Servants per 100,000 Residents
- India: 1,622.8, US: 7,681
- IAS Officer Shortfall
- 23% shortfall in sanctioned positions (2018)